Attaching Trayvon Martin to Net Neutrality: Inaccurate and Inappropriate

Attaching Trayvon Martin to Net Neutrality: Inaccurate and Inappropriate






By Daryl Bassett, former Utility Commissioner, Arkansas Public Service Commission

I’ve spent over twenty years convening diverse groups of people and organizations around the causes that can help improve our society.  Success in bringing about social change relies not only on passion for seeing a more equitable and just world, but relies also on accuracy of the information exchanged between myself and the groups I bring together.  From accuracy flows the transparency, credibility, and trust that form the bedrock of relationships going forward.  It also goes a long way in presenting an image to the public that the coalition you build is one that should be taken seriously; a coalition that is empowered and can help infuse empowerment.

That is why I am, to put it lightly, befuddled by an article published in April on the website that argues if the Federal Communications Commission’s proposed rules to allow broadband providers to charge content providers for providing  faster lanes for their content were in place at the time of Trayvon Martin’s death, his story would not have been catapulted to national view.

First, let’s look at what we know of the proposed rules.  The proposed rules have three main components.

The first component is an anti-blocking provision that basically prohibits an Internet service provider (ISP)from preventing  a consumer from accessing legal content from any website.  So whether you want to visit the website of either The New York Times or General Motors, you will be able to reach either site.

The second component is closely related to the first.  Your ISP, say Charter Communications, cannot discriminate among the content flowing from The New York Times or General Motors.  They would have to treat them equally when it comes to their speed of traffic.  In other words, the ISP could not throttle the download speeds of either content provider.

The first two components are not controversial.  Internet access providers have been adhering to these principles since consumers had commercial access to the Internet.  It’s simply not good business to block consumer access to websites or arbitrarily choose which website would be the content provider of the day.  Consumers would think twice about adopting broadband and the value of the network to investors would decrease.

However, the third component of the proposed rules is the source of the controversy.  This component allows content providers and ISP’s to enter an arrangement where, for a fee, the ISP opens up a faster lane for the content provider.  For a company like Netflix which now accounts for 31% of traffic flowing through the Internet, the extra lane goes a long way to ensuring consumers get a quality of video experience.  Nothing is wrong with that.  What is wrong, however, is implying that this type of arrangement would prevent us from getting important issues in front of national media.  Nothing could be further from the truth.  In fact, I would argue the opposite.

The anti-blocking and anti-discrimination principles already in place when Trayvon Martin was killed ensured that websites and blogs kept the passing of Mr. Martin in the community’s consciousness.  Access to these blogs and websites were not blocked by ISPs.  No amount of web speed, however, would have garnered his story national media attention.  It was the tenacity of his family and their legal team that got him the media attention he deserved.

Allowing arrangements where a content provider pays an ISP to open another lane would have had no impact on smaller websites and blogs addressing Mr. Martin’s death.  Under theproposed rule a content provider entering such an arrangement with an ISP would receive a faster lane for its traffic to travel on.  The speeds at which other smaller providers are sending their data would not change.

Lastly, tying Trayvon Martin’s death to a discussion on net neutrality was inappropriate.  There is no passion in the argument because the premise is false.  It reeks of desperation.  It would be one thing to argue, and justifiably so, that the lack of national media attention to the shooting was in part due to a lack of diversity in national media.  If we owned more media outlets maybe the results would have been different.  But to say that the lack of national media coverage would have been severely eroded by a policy that allows Netflix greater bandwidth to send videos is a stretch, a big stretch.

If we are to maintain credible and influential voices in any policy debate, our arguments should be rational and factual minus the desperate reach for the emotional.


  1. The problem has been the focus on irrelevant arguments – some of which are actually unsupported by the evidence.

    1. ‘George Zimmerman (GZ) racially profiled Trayvon Martin (TM)’ There is no evidence of this.

    2. ‘GZ disobeyed an order by the police’ * The civilian dispatcher, Sean Noffke, testified that he did not give GZ an order and, in fact, he, like his fellow dispatchers, are trained not make comments that sound like commands. * Noffke also testified under cross that, as a result of his asking GZ which way TM was going, GZ could have reasonably interpreted this as being asked to follow Martin. * It is also not a crime in Florida to disregard a comment made by a civilian dispatcher.

    3. ‘GZ got out of his car’ Not a crime on public property and not negligent either.

    4. ‘GZ followed TM’ Again, anyone can follow anyone on a public street unless the followee has obtained a restraining order against the follower and even there, the RS only places time, place, and manner restrictions on the person enjoined.

    5. ‘GZ wasn’t really injured’ * Under Florida’s self-defense laws, one doesn’t have to be injured AT ALL to use deadly force * No one is required to refrain from defending himself while another is engaged in or attempting to commit a felony.

    6. ‘TM is dead through no fault of his own’ * If you believe that TM assaulted GZ, then he IS dead as a result of his own actions.

    7. ‘GZ could have left’ * Under Florida law, there is not a duty to withdraw rather than use deadly force * TM was straddling GZ so how the latter was supposed to leave the scene is unanswered.

    8. ‘GZ was armed and TM wasn’t’ * One’s fists can be considered weapons and can result in severe bodily harm or death. * GZ was legally carrying a weapon * There is no requirement under the law that the same weapon be used by the assailant * A homeowner can kill an intruder whether or not he has been threatened * Those that attack cannot feign surprise if they are met with superior firepower.

    9. ‘Stand Your Ground!’ * SYG is NOT at issue in this trial. * The defense is a classic self-defense case.

    10. ‘Black men NEVER get to use SYG!’ * Wrong

    11. ‘GZ is a man and TM was a boy!’ * As if ‘boys’ don’t commit murder, rape, and assault everyday in this country.

  2. The game is harder to bluff since you are capable
    to watch the eyes in the other players since the communal cards are
    exposed. For example, I know a great number of men and women who feel that it’s actually a parent’s responsibility,
    or expectation, that they can should spend on their children’s college
    Futures contract trade with a wide selection of Treasury security maturities.
    So permit’s fall behind the slippery gross sales discuss
    and also choose a please take a look at this method.

    Money management is really the engine that drives this vehicle so
    understanding how much you’ve to bet and what you have left to
    bet is fundamental for this venture. Always be sure you change
    your bet during a session so that it accompanies your performance inside the game.

  3. best gaming laptops under 500 pounds

    He or she can leave it for the people who are very well versed inside technical details of scriptwriting.
    If you’re a devoted reader, than the should not be described as a problem in your case.
    Good gaming laptops under 1000 2013 specifying,, In writing letters,
    if appropriate, drawing a flower, heart, kiss makes personal letters
    loved. You can look for top websites selling clothes online
    with the help of major search engines.

  4. rca jack to hdmi adapter

    You can calculate keyword-density by dividing the sum of every keyword by
    the sum of words in the copy. Technical manuals, technical specification guides,
    support manuals, implementation guides – all are types of technical documentation and are a part in the job.
    hdmi to rca converter cable best buy Many turn out fond of writing along with the main objective
    of elementary writing prompts is usually to provide suggestions to the kids
    to create on topics that will interest them. Take another angle: Your travel writing doesn

  5. Clean up your entire you will find make certain no food is scattered
    anywhere within the home, along with remove any shelter that this mouse may like.
    At the top of the keyboard, you’ll find special sound keys that allow you to
    definitely adjust the volume of one’s game or movies with just several buttons.
    Zebronics gaming mouse Customizable LED lights:
    Gaming mice includes LED lights which can be set to the color desired from the player, latest hardware allows
    several colour selections for LED lights.

    But some smart marketing minds have slowly accumulated this segment,
    and you can find now outstanding gaming mice available that even non-gamers might discover how to
    love. With all of these features combined, the Sentinel Advance may be the most effective gaming mouse now available on the market industry.

    In performance reviews, of what areas do you receive the greatest scores
    or the most positive feedback. The best strategy to
    ensure which you’ve created an understandable, complete document is to employ a third
    party reader. Gaming mouse for lol instead ( Your ideas should be clicked your reader

  6. Many toy makers gathered within the Pearl River Delta region and they claimed that
    they’re facing rising labor cost, which constrained the reform and upgrade.
    So, let’s have a breakdown with the different age ranges for buying childrens toys and choosing the most effective
    toys to keep them entertained for as long as you possibly can. Nerf magstrike So move it, and rush for the toy store to grab some Ben 10 toys Your kids will enjoy it and you will stay happy because you
    see them being engaged and learning interesting things with their toys.

    In recent years, the interest in stress relief toys is growing exponentially, and
    so has their variety. One may even make money out or playing by through legal competition that’s been set up by
    way of a group of RC toy lovers.

    It has roots in culture, art, history, style, glamour and almost every
    other sphere imaginable. You should write these notes on the question paper, in lieu of the answer sheet, so then you definitely know that they can examiner is not going to read them as part of your answer.
    Nerf demolisher walmart somethan ( And if you get a few chapters
    done also it doesn’t feel correct, experiment by writing it in another
    style and find out how it feels then. It’s surprising, though, just the
    number of writers unconsciously lose control of the items they are writing and wander off into other
    writing forms.

  7. By contrast, LEDs use only 20% of the power and so they use the majority of it
    see how to avoid generation. A plant will stop able to create food inside absence
    of light and so will ‘t be able to grow at all. Xtreme led grow lights The concentration of
    light will likely be just as vital in your garden as is also quality.

    This light wavelength really should not be shone in the eye or be used often at night
    because it might be either distracting or blinding for the eyes in case you might not feel any effects.
    With all the talk about the environment suffering with the hands of humans, having an Eco
    friendly as well as saving LED Grow Light will help
    reduce your footprint about the environment.

    There are lots of reasons that you simply may chose to write poetry but the primary reason is that you just want to publish.
    Courses on business writing are also offered by various workshops.

    due ( led grow lights philips Can you distinguish yourself
    by the geographic area you’re working in or maybe your years of experience.
    Depending on what sort of technical writing you’re doing, many
    will apply, plus some won’t.

  8. pill ingredients

    While writing such letters, a person has to follow certain rules.

    this notice, plus notify us in the day(s) you will probably be
    running it. number ( ebay orovo
    Most are happy to tout various websites as the following
    big online outlet, where piles of free money are just ready for a lot of
    aspiring author to assert them. Standard to Particular:
    Start with a broad or broad statement followed by facts and examples.

  9. Their such as you read through my thoughts! You seem to knowledge a great deal of relating to this, such as you composed a booklet in it something like that. I have faith that you merely can do by r. d. to force your message property slightly, but instead of this, this can be exceptional blog. An incredible read through. I’ll absolutely return.. T'ai Chi Ch'uan (Martial Art), Chen-style T'ai Chi Ch'uan, explicación de Tai Chi, aplications of Taichi, Style, Martial Arts (Sport), Combat (Media Genre), Tai Chi, Pushing Hands, Chen Xiao Wang, Ma Hong, Chen Zhaokui, feng zhi qiang, Fighting, Estilo Chen, Fight, Taiji, Taiji Quan, Pan zhencai, Chen Fake, forma 83, defense, chen fake, Freestyle, Combat, fighting, taiji, Karate, Master, qigong, health, martai, power, Arts, Free, yang, tsao, self, kung, arts

  10. I such as beneficial details you offer with your articles or blog posts.. chen taijiquan music,chen taijiquan form,Tai chi – Martial Art,tai chi chuan,hai chi tai,tai chi quan I am going to save your website and check out once more in this article usually. I’m fairly certain We’ll study quite a few innovative goods proper here! Best of luck for the next!

  11. Appreciating the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed
    information you present. It’s nice to come across a blog
    every once in a while that isn’t the same out of date rehashed material.
    Great read! I’ve saved your site and I’m including your RSS feeds to my Google account.