5:13pm May 28, 2014

Justice Reform? 22 Black Caucus Members Vote YES to 3 Mandatory Minimums


Twenty-two Black Caucus members vote for the #1 driver in over incarceration. Last week, the House voted on the SAVE ACT. It passed 392-19. Incredibly, given the effect of over incarceration on the Black community over three decades — 22 members of the Black Caucus voted for the bill which included three mandatory minimum sentencing penalties. The bill seeks to punish anyone who benefits financially from sex trafficking.

Kemba Smith, Clarence Aron, Marissa Alexander… in an age when there are protests over mandatory minimum cases featuring long sentences for non-violent offenses, one would think the Black Caucus would have a set policy against mandatory minimums.


From the new National Academy of Sciences study on over incarceration.

Only 13 Black Caucus members voted against the SAVE Act with its three new mandatory penalties including the Chair of the Black Caucus, Rep. Marcia Fudge. Fudge was joined in opposition by a freshman Republican member from Kentucky: Rep. Tom Massie (R-KY) who is an example of the growing GOP opposition to mandatory sentences. While Massie, whose district is only 2.3% Black, voted against the bill because of the three mandatory minimums, 22 Black Caucus members vote in favor of a primary driver of over incarceration.

Rep. Massie has joined Rep. Bobby Scott in pushing the Justice Safety Valve Act of 2013. That bill would give federal judges the flexibility to issue sentences below the mandatory minimum penalty. Currently the Senate is working on a bill that would give judges more sentencing flexibility. Even Tea Party Republican Senators Rand Paul and Mike Lee support rolling back mandatory minimums.


The three mandatory penalties in the SAVE Act.

Who in the Black Caucus voted for three mandatory minimums? Here’s a list: Reps. Joyce Beatty, Karen Bass, Sanford Bishop, G.K. Butterfield, Andre Carson, Lacy Clay, Emanuel Cleaver, Elijah Cummings, Chaka Fattah, Al Green, Alcee Hastings, Steve Horsford, Robin Kelly, Sheila Jackson Lee, Eddie Bernice Johnson, Greg Meeks, Don Payne, Charlie Rangel, Cedric Richmond, Terri Sewell, Marc Veasey and Frederica Wilson [Hank Johnson, Bobby Rush and Bennie Thompson did not vote].

Did a bunch of Legislative Directors in Black Caucus offices fall asleep on May 20? At this point in the game after 30 years of evidence that mandatory sentences drive over incarceration isn’t it obvious that mandatory minimums are bad policy?

RELATED: Aug. 2013: Meet Five People Serving Draconian Drug Sentences Thanks To Mandatory Minimum Laws

The impact on Black and Hispanic communities has been undeniable. On May 24, the New York Times published a crushing editorial called End Mass Incarceration Now. Of course the editorial mentions mandatory minimums. It also mentions yet another study by the National Academy of Sciences that presents even more back breaking undeniable info on the consequences of over incarceration.

If you’re thinking, “hey, this is sex crime legislation so a mandatory sentence is OK,” think again. In the past mandatory minimums have had an uncanny way of causing unintended sentencing consequences.

“The legislation puts the Craigslist ad person on same level as the ringleader kidnapper who sets up a safe house and is the ringleader in the sex trafficking,” says Molly Gill, Government Affairs Counsel for Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM).

“Every crime is unique and every person who commits it is unique,” Gill added. She also made the point that when it comes to Congress voting on mandatory minimums, there is a crime du jour factor. “Whatever the big high profile crime is, Congress slaps a mandatory minimum on it, sex trafficking is the crime du jour of the day — it’s legislation without a lot of forethought — crime is more complicated than that,” Gill added.



About the Author

Lauren Victoria Burke
Lauren Victoria Burke
Lauren Victoria Burke is an opinion journalist, comms expert and political analyst focused on justice reform policy. She created Crewof42.com, a blog that covers the work of Black members of Congress, in 2009. Ms. Burke was a staffer for the Senate Democratic Policy Committee and Director of Communications for Rep. Andre Carson (D-IN). She has had a very diverse career in politics and media and appears regularly on NewsOneNow with Roland Martin, Hardball and Up on MSNBC, WVON in Chicago, WURD in Philadelphia and WOL and WHUR in Washington, D.C. She is currently the Managing Editor of Politic365 and a contributing writer for TheRoot and NBC Black where she writes opinion and analysis. Additionally, Ms. Burke has been a contract photographer for Associated Press since 2004. She has authored three books of photography including two on President Obama's 2008 campaign for the presidency and one with Marvel Comics publisher Stan Lee. Ms. Burke was born in the Bronx, New York and grew up on Long Island. She holds a B.A. in History from The American University. Here e-mail is: LBurke007@gmail.com. Twitter: @LVBurke. Instagram: LVB325.



H.R. 3713: Urban League, FAMM Voice Concerns on #JusticeReform Bills

In a striking statement that’s a departure from the views of other major civil rights groups, National Urban League President Marc Morial expressed concerns with the two leading sentencing reform bills in Congress: S. 212...
by Lauren Victoria Burke


Rep. John Conyers Supports Criminal Intent Bill, Catches Hell From Left

Other Democrats have been criticized for it, but they weren’t in the position of actually passing legislation on the issue. As of yesterday, the most senior Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee is.  Rep. John Conyer...
by Lauren Victoria Burke


Nov. 18: Goodlatte-Conyers Bill with New Heroin Penalty Heads to Cmte.

Legislation authored by House Judiciary Chairman Bob Goodlatte (R-VA) and ranking Democrat John Conyers (D-MI) that includes an expanded penalty for heroin containing fentanyl, will be considered by the full House Judiciary Co...
by Lauren Victoria Burke



Hollande Plans Response to Worst Attack in Paris Since WWII

French President Francois Hollande is preparing a response to the attacks on his country. “This is an act of war” Hollande said regarding the near-simultaneous attacks in Paris that killed nearly 130 people and lef...
by Lauren Victoria Burke


Someone Ask Bobby Jindal to Explain Glenn Ford and Albert Woodfox

“What’s your biggest weakness,” was the first debate question for 8 Republican candidates for President one night.  Someone could have answered for Louisiana’s Governor Bobby Jindal, because the answer ...
by Lauren Victoria Burke


One Comment

  1. […] Justice Reform? 22 Black Caucus Members Vote YES to 3 Mandatory Minimums Twenty-two Black Caucus members vote for the #1 driver in over incarceration. Last week, the House voted on the SAVE ACT. It passed 392-19. Incredibly, given the effect of over incarceration on the Black community over three decades — 22 members of … Read more on Politic365 […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>