3:15pm July 11, 2013

U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Value of Diversity in Higher Education

Fisher v. Texas dvierstiy

On Monday, June 24, 2013, the United States Supreme Court issued its long-awaited decision in the Fisher v. UT Austin case. In that case, the Caucasian plaintiff, Abigail Fisher, challenged the admissions program of The University of Texas at Austin (UT) and contended that her denial of admission violated the Equal Protection Clause of the United States Constitution. This was a highly watched case and over 70 amicus briefs were filed, most in support of UT’s holistic admissions process which considers an applicant’s race/ethnicity as one of several factors regarding admission to the school.

The case is especially significant for diversity and inclusion practitioners.  While the plaintiff purported not to challenge existing law, there was considerable concern that the high Court might do just that, overrule the Michigan Law School case.  In Grutter v. Bollinger, decided in 2003, the Supreme Court upheld the Law School’s use of race/ethnicity as one of several “plus factors” in an admissions process that evaluated the overall individual contribution of each candidate for admissions.   The Court recognized that Michigan had a compelling state interest is achieving the educational benefits of a diverse  student body.  The Court’s agreement to review the Fisher case so soon after the Grutter decision put the holding of the Michigan case at risk.

In its 7-1 opinion, the Court remanded the Fisher case to the Fifth Circuit for consideration under a strict scrutiny standard of review. In short, the Court vacated the favorable decision for UT, which had been appealed by Ms. Fisher, and concluded that the lower court had not followed the correct legal standard.

Significantly, the existing precedent established in the Michigan case regarding the importance of diversity in the educational context remains valid.

The fight to preserve the benefits of a diverse classroom is far from over, but at least for today, the right to try to achieve them remains.

As UT’s President Bill Powers stated following the Fisher decision: “We’re encouraged by the Supreme Court’s ruling in this case. We will continue to defend the University’s admission policy on remand in the lower court under the strict standards that the Court first articulated in the Bakke case, reaffirmed in the Grutter case, and laid out again today. We believe the University’s policy fully satisfies those standards. We remain committed to assembling a student body at The University of Texas at Austin that provides the educational benefits of diversity on campus while respecting the rights of all students and acting within the constitutional framework established by the Court.”

As diversity and inclusion practitioners, we recognize the value of diversity — from the classroom to the boardroom.  And as the demographics of our country continue to move toward a more ethnically diverse population, we must protect the ability of all students, our future employees and leaders, to derive the benefits of a diverse learning environment.


Elizabeth A. Campbell is a Partner and Chief Diversity Officer for Andrews Kurth LLP and is a member of True Blue Inclusion.  She is responsible for the development and implementation of the diversity and inclusion components of the firm’s strategic plan, and collaborates with the firm’s Labor and Employment Section attorneys and is a frequent speaker, training facilitator and author on the topic of diversity and inclusion and related employment law topics.  Along with her partners Gene Locke and Lino Mendiola, Elizabeth filed an amicus brief in the Fisher case on behalf of the Houston Community College System supporting the admissions program of UT.


About the Author

Guest Contributor
Guest Contributor
The ideas and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author, and have complete editorial independence from any Politic365 partners, sponsors, or advertisers. For additional information about Politic365, please visit http://politic365.com/about/.



Obama Administration Takes Historic Step Toward Solar Equality, But Much Work Remains

This article originally appeared on Huffington Post, and has been cross-posted at the author’s request. For far too long, working-class families have been left out of the solar revolution in the United States. Black elect...
by Guest Contributor


We Are Moving FORWARD!

This piece first appeared on Cognitive Relevance, and has been reposted with permission from the author. I laughed first when I read Ted Cruz’s comment on the SCOTUS decision Friday legalizing gay marriage in America. The...
by Guest Contributor

Screen Shot 2015-05-16 at 7.11.23 PM

Loretta Sanchez mocks Native Americans at California Democratic Convention

Today Congresswoman Loretta Sanchez mocked Native Americans at the California Democratic Convention in Anaheim. While in front of an audience, the Congresswoman, who is also a recently declared candidate for U.S. Senate, recoun...
by Adriana Maestas



NCLR: Helping to Build Resilient Latino Youth

Immigration, poverty, education, discrimination, disengagement are all issues affecting Latino youth today and the National Council of La Raza (NCLR) is leading the charge for an open dialogue on these issues. NCLR is the Natio...
by Charlyn Stanberry


Lorretta Johnson: Breaking Barriers and Uniting Educators

For the last 50 years, Lorretta Johnson has advocated for educators across the country. Her journey has taken her to the poorest neighborhoods in the United States, to the Rose Garden of the White House, and all around the worl...
by Sam P.K. Collins



  1. […] U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Value of Diversity in Higher Education This article, from a website devoted to analysis of politics and policy related to communities of color, analyzes the Fisher decision from a point of view that advocates for diversity in higher education. (Source: politic365.com, July 11, 2013) […]

  2. Hi to every body, it’s my first pay a visit
    of this blog; this blog carries amazing and genuinely fine information for visitors.

    Stop by my web-site: club k fastpitch softball training facility [http://hittheballhard.weebly.Com/]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>