3:40pm May 3, 2013

Paul Ryan’s Anti-Immigrant Rhetoric Makes Him an Odd Reform Advocate


Self deportation, anchor babies, catch and release, illegal — these are not the words you expect to hear from the mouth of an immigration reform advocate, but they are examples of some of the type of language used by Wisconsin Congressmen Paul Ryan as he remakes himself as a pro-immigrant Republican.

Earlier this week at a town hall meeting in Burlington, Wisconsin Ryan explained to his constituents that the children of immigrants are “anchor babies,” because they are U.S. citizens. He made these comments while framing the issue of immigration reform of the best way to deny immigrants benefits before they become citizens.

Previously Ryan, who recently teamed up with Illinois Congressman Luis Gutierrez-D, who has made immigration the centerpiece of his career, supported a “self-deportation” policy as a vice presidential candidate in the 2012 election. Just a few days ago, by Gutierrez’s side, Ryan called noted the need for reform because, “We have a broken immigration system and, if anything, what we see in Boston is that we have to fix and modernize our immigration system.”

He also previously referred to “catch and release” tactics when referring to immigrants, outraging some of his constituents at the language often used to describe fish.

Ryan had previously voted against the DREAM Act, interesting considering the immigration reform legislation he’s currently pushing contains similar legislation, and has been very pro-border enforcement in the past. He’s also voted to make unauthorized immigration a criminal, as opposed to civil, offense, wanted to make it harder for immigrants to obtain driver’s licenses, supported making local police immigration enforcers and also wanted hospitals to take legal status into account while treating patients.

From 2000 to 2010, Wisconsin’s Latino population grew 74%, but Ryan’s district is outside of Milwaukee, where the majority of Latinos in Wisconsin are concentrated. Whether they are in Milwaukee or not, Latinos in the state are one of the fastest growing groups.

People in Wisconsin were disappointed by Ryan’s choice of words this week.

“It’s really disappointing to hear that from Congressman Ryan, especially when he’s shown signs of moving forward in this somewhat productive way on pushing for a real comprehensive immigration reform,” said Joe Shansky, of Voces de la Frontera, an immigrants’ rights group in Milwaukee.

“Actually,” Shansky added, “It’s disgusting that he’d resort to that really dehumanizing language.”

Other Democrats and Latinos in the state have pointed to Ryan’s ties to the Tea Party movement, which has been much more sympathetic to anti-immigrant figures like Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio than Congressman Luis Gutierrez, for example. Some see Ryan’s pursuit of immigration reform as part of his future presidential aspirations.

“It’s especially sad because he’s talking about his constituents,” said Shanksy, of Voces de la Frontera. “I hope that he can speak about his constituents in a more respectful and productive manner.”

About the Author

Sara Inés Calderón
Sara Inés Calderón
Sara Inés Calderón is a journalist and writer bouncing between California and Texas.



H.R. 3713: Urban League, FAMM Voice Concerns on #JusticeReform Bills

In a striking statement that’s a departure from the views of other major civil rights groups, National Urban League President Marc Morial expressed concerns with the two leading sentencing reform bills in Congress: S. 212...
by Lauren Victoria Burke


Rep. John Conyers Supports Criminal Intent Bill, Catches Hell From Left

Other Democrats have been criticized for it, but they weren’t in the position of actually passing legislation on the issue. As of yesterday, the most senior Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee is.  Rep. John Conyer...
by Lauren Victoria Burke


Nov. 18: Goodlatte-Conyers Bill with New Heroin Penalty Heads to Cmte.

Legislation authored by House Judiciary Chairman Bob Goodlatte (R-VA) and ranking Democrat John Conyers (D-MI) that includes an expanded penalty for heroin containing fentanyl, will be considered by the full House Judiciary Co...
by Lauren Victoria Burke



Hollande Plans Response to Worst Attack in Paris Since WWII

French President Francois Hollande is preparing a response to the attacks on his country. “This is an act of war” Hollande said regarding the near-simultaneous attacks in Paris that killed nearly 130 people and lef...
by Lauren Victoria Burke


Someone Ask Bobby Jindal to Explain Glenn Ford and Albert Woodfox

“What’s your biggest weakness,” was the first debate question for 8 Republican candidates for President one night.  Someone could have answered for Louisiana’s Governor Bobby Jindal, because the answer ...
by Lauren Victoria Burke



  1. [...] Paul Ryan’s Anti-Immigrant Rhetoric Makes Him an Odd Reform Advocate [...]

  2. [...] [ Paul Ryan's Anti-Immigrant Rhetoric Makes Him an Odd Reform Advocate, Sara Inés Calderón, Politics 365, May 3, 2013] [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>