Politic365

 
 


Grito

4:38pm March 25, 2013

Death Penalty Strikes Out Again in Puerto Rico

2012-09-27t000937z_249793774_gm1e89r0mcz01_rtrmadp_3_puertorico

On Saturday, a lone juror in a criminal case before the U.S. District Court for the District of Puerto Rico was all that stood between the Alexis Candelario Santana and the death penalty. The Federal Prosecutors wanted to get a death penalty conviction for a man responsible for more murders than Jeffrey Dahmer had victims and the mastermind behind the “Tombola massacre” that shocked Puerto Rico in 2009. The lone juror, a woman according to El Nuevo Día, was the reason Candelario will now face life in prison, instead of the death penalty. Governor Garcia Padilla lauded the decision by the jury, stating:

“I express my most profound respect to the jury for the decision it has taken. With it they have sustained the conviction of the Puerto Rican people that capital punishment should not be applied under any circumstances…”

While Pedro Pierluisi, president of the Statehood Party and representative before Congress for Puerto Rico, coincided with the Governor and added that the verdict is proof that Puerto Ricans will not impose the death penalty under any circumstance. That said, the verdict brings several issues to light in Puerto Rico.

The first issue one must address in the death penalty debate in Puerto Rico is the federal/state divide. Namely, Puerto Rico’s Constitution prohibits the death penalty, while the federal Constitution allows it. Until the 1990s, federal prosecutors did not seek the death penalty in Puerto Rico. However, following a court decision in 2001 where the Court of Appeals for the First Circuit held that the legal framework concerning Puerto Rico’s relationship with the U.S. did not bar the death penalty in federal cases, prosecutors have been more aggressive in seeking the death penalty here on the Island (this being the 5th time it has been placed before a local jury). Some, including the State Bar Association, view the local constitution as a clear impediment to the Federal Government’s quest to impose the death penalty, ignoring the fact that the federal constitution has no duty to pay heed to the local constitution. Opponents of the death penalty argue that Puerto Ricans by and large reject it, and that it has no place in our culture even though the last two cases were decided by a single juror (instead of an overwhelming rejection by said jury).

Another point to consider is the contradiction between the message made by opponents of the death penalty and the facts on the ground. Following the verdict, opponents cheered the decision and lauded Puerto Rico’s commitment to civil values, respect for life and “civilization.” However, this “respect to civil values” goes ignored in the spiraling crime rate faced by the island, with over 1,000 murders per year for the past 2 years, without counting the intolerable levels of gun and gang violence, rape and home invasions. To those who lauded Puerto Rican’s value based on a jury verdict, the message seems to be lost on the victims of everyday crime. Puerto Rico has, contrary to what Pierluisi claims, a culture that is highly tolerable of death when one sees the crime wave hitting the Island, not only in the past few years, but in the past decades. Additionally, the last two cases have rejected the death penalty not because a majority of jurors rejected it, but because one single juror did not agree. This means that out of 12 jurors, 11 were ready to pull the “switch” on the accused, hardly a strong showing of a culture that rejects the death penalty.

The issue will no doubt come again as the local federal court has another case in which the death penalty is being sought in the next month. Puerto Rico will have another chance to either hold the line on its opposition to the death penalty, or break with its history and embrace stronger tactics in the fight against crime.

 



About the Author

jeanvidal





 
 

 
cleaver2

Black Caucus Announces Plan to Boost the Black Vote for 2014

Congressional Black Caucus Chair Marcia Fudge (D-OH), CBCPAC Chair Greg Meeks (D-NY), Rep. Emanuel Cleaver (D-MO) and Rep. Jim Clyburn (D-SC) announced their plans to boost black voter turnout for the midterms.   They were joi...
by Lauren Victoria Burke
0

 
 
slideshow_1210556_healthreform.0810_10

#Ferguson: Rep. Hank Johnson’s Police Demilitarization Bill Gets GOP Support

Three Republicans have signed on to Rep. Hank Johnson’s (D-GA) bill to stop handing free military equipment to local  police.  The three Republicans are Reps. Raul Labrador (R-ID), Tom McClintock (R-CA) and Justin Amas...
by Lauren Victoria Burke
0

 
 
markFuller1

Members of Congress Vocal on Ray Rice Go Silent Federal Judge Mark Fuller

After Roland Martin shined a spotlight on Alabama Judge Mark Fuller, Congresswoman Terri Sewell became the first member of Congress to call for the federal judge’s resignation.  Why? Because in the wake of the scandal ov...
by Lauren Victoria Burke
2

 

Advertisement
 
Screen Shot 2014-09-15 at 9.38.57 PM

CA State Sen. Roderick Wright to resign this month, following criminal conviction

California State Senator Roderick Wright (D-Inglewood) announced on Monday that he would resign from the state legislature effective September 22. This comes after being convicted for felony perjury and voting fraud charges for...
by Adriana Maestas
2

 
 
hillaryA

Iowa: DREAMers Ask Hillary About Immigration, Get No Answers

DREAMers asked Hillary Clinton about the issue of President Obama’s latest delay on immigration.  Clinton, along with her husband, were in Iowa today at Sen. Harkin’s famous 37th (and final) annual Steak Fry in I...
by Lauren Victoria Burke
0

 




One Comment


  1. Get one of your. judges to mandate that a Dr
    can only administor the chemicals that will lead to deth. then because the hip .oath do no harm. well put it on hold



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>