11:12am December 4, 2012

Redefining Welfare


A favorite whipping boy of Republicans and conservative ideologues is welfare. Among all discretionary spending programs, TANF, Temporary Assistance to Needy Families, formerly known as AFDC (Aid to Families with Dependent Children) before the welfare reform “miracle” of 1996, is the program that Romney means when he talks about the 47% of moochers that would never vote for him.

There are many other programs that provide benefits to people, but TANF is the classic example of welfare because it is low, or no income Americans receiving cash assistance for a defined period of time. Republicans hate this program because they argue it fosters dependency on the government.

Yet, federal, state and local budgets are full of many other examples of public largesse showered on non-poor individuals and corporations with no real return on the dollar.

Look at Medicare for an example. Since its inception, Medicare has been treated as a sacred cow that cannot be tinkered with and it is practically sacrilege to suggest that Medicare recipients are on “welfare” despite the fact that an average worker will receive more in Medicare benefits over their lifetime than the amount they paid. The New York Times even writes, “For most Americans, Medicare resembles a giant welfare program.” Medicare is also the single biggest program busting the federal budget, yet any mention of raising the Medicare tax to pay for these shortfalls met with strong resistance by the AARP.

For years, local and state governments have engaged in a “folly of corporate relocation” offering $50 – 80 billion a year in incentives that do not create new jobs (the federal government will dole out an additional $100 billion). Jobs are simply shifted around the country as local governments outbid each other to see who can most destitute their local school system merely so that a politician can say they’ve “created jobs.”

General Motors knows how to exploit governments as well as any company out there, while Texas is the worst state at this behavior, doling out $19 billion a year in free public money to big businesses. Local school boards have provided $1.9 billion in tax abatements. Despite this lavish treatment offered to corporate America, the Lone Star state still had to cut education spending by $5.4 billion last year. This leads to an unmistakable conclusion that corporate tax breaks exacerbate widening income inequality. Corporations get richer while education cuts inevitably lead a more defined “haves” and “have not’s” society.

Until Americans see corporate subsidies as welfare, it will be poor individuals that don’t have armies of lobbyists, lawyers, and accountants who will continue get the short shrift from government.

About the Author

Marvin King
Marvin King
Marvin King received his Ph.D. in Political Science from the University of North Texas and his B.A. from the University of Texas. Now, he is an Associate Professor of Political Science with a joint appointment in the African American Studies Program at the University of Mississippi. He conducts research into how political institutions affect African American politics. Marvin is available for public speaking engagements and you can follow him on Twitter @kingpolitics



Comcast Extends Internet Essentials Indefinitely, Grants $1 Million for Learning Zones

Comcast’s recent announcement that it will extend its Internet Essentials program indefinitely, and will expand it to Time Warner Cable markets pending closure of their merger, is welcome news. The digital divide is a serious...
by Kristal High


New report highlights dire Latino voter situation in Texas

In Texas, Latinos are projected to reach a plurality of the population (43%), and for the past few years, politicians and operatives have been buzzing about tapping into this growing population to loosen the GOP grip on the sta...
by Adriana Maestas


Verizon Invests $600 Million in America’s Future

This week Verizon Communications Inc. made announcements about two major investments it’s making totaling a $600 million infusion into the educational and economic sectors of this country. On Tuesday, the nation’s second la...
by Kristal High



National African American History Month 2014: Civil Rights in America

Progress in America has never come easy. Through centuries of struggle and hard-won victories, our country has been shaped by generations of Americans who believed this could be the Nation envisioned in our founding principles ...
by Guest Contributor


MMTC Focuses on the Digital Divide and Tech Driven Economic Opportunity

On January 15th in Washington, a congressional luncheon was held as part of the Minority Media and Telecommunications Council’s (MMTC) 5th Annual Broadband and Social Justice Summit. This year’s Summit was entitled,...
by Lauren Victoria Burke



Be the first to comment!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>