12:18pm November 21, 2012

Ryan, Cantor, Boehner and the Failure of the 2012 Election


Why is political compromise so difficult? In an election year where Congress’s approval ratings are historically low, Americans still returned more than 90% of the incumbents who stood for reelection. This happens because of the age-old adage that Americans hate Congress but love their congressperson.

Through the magic of districting congressional boundaries, we have a system where it is the politicians themselves (mostly state legislators) that are responsible for jerry rigging, ahem…make that gerrymandering their districts to be as favorable as possible for their own reelection.

So now Paul Ryan, who Americans summarily rejected at the polls two weeks ago, is now back in charge of the House Budget Committee. Along with Speaker John Boehner and Minority Leader Eric Cantor, the three will represent House Republicans in fiscal cliff negotiations with the Senate and the White House.

It is as if we might as well have not even had the election.

All the power players are back.

The difference is Ryan is the only one of the negotiators who lost an election on November 6. The so-called Ryan budget was very much an election year issue, yet a majority of Americans rejected it. The substance of the Ryan budget was that taxes not be raised. Yet, on Election Day, Speaker Boehner told Politico, “We’ll have as much of a mandate as he [President Obama] will … to not raise taxes. He knows what we can do and what we can’t do — I’ve been very upfront with him about it going back over the last year and a half.”

That does not sound like a person or a party ready to compromise.

Given that Boehner, Cantor, Ryan and most every other congressperson, Republican and Democratic alike, come from exceedingly safe districts, they have no personal need to compromise. Their districts are drawn in such a way as to elect either a Republican or a Democrat, but not both.

Even in big swing elections that change the majority party in the House, only 50 or 60 seats out of 435 change hands. The odds of one hundred or more seats switching party’s in any given election are quite small.

Yet, given the dangers of a repeated recession due to the drastic and immediate spending cuts caused by the fiscal cliff, all the 2012 election accomplished was to create a very dangerous game of chicken comprised of the exact same cast of characters that created the fiscal cliff to begin with.

About the Author

Marvin King
Marvin King
Marvin King received his Ph.D. in Political Science from the University of North Texas and his B.A. from the University of Texas. Now, he is an Associate Professor of Political Science with a joint appointment in the African American Studies Program at the University of Mississippi. He conducts research into how political institutions affect African American politics. Marvin is available for public speaking engagements and you can follow him on Twitter @kingpolitics



#GA123: The Children of Freedom Summer Will Soon Be Leaders of Freedom Fall

The seeds planted 50 years ago in Mississippi during Freedom Summer are in full bloom. The children of 1964 — who are now leaders — are positioned to energize this generation of young voters of color and progressive...
by Kirk Clay


Poll: majority of voters in Rep. Cantor’s district support immigration reform

Last night House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-VA) lost his primary to Dave Brat, a tea party backed college professor. Brat beat Cantor with 56% of the vote to Cantor’s 44%, but some in the media have said that Cantor&#...
by Adriana Maestas


Rep. Eric Cantor campaigns on anti-immigrant messaging

It’s been a little over a week sincethe Obama administration announced that it would delay a review of deportation policies to give the House of Representatives “space” to advance an immigration reform bill, a...
by Adriana Maestas


Georgians Go To The Polls During Early Voting Before General Election

Election 2014: Georgia 1+2+3 = Modern Voting Rights Movement #GA123

Last week I participated in #GA123 — one of the most cutting edge civic engagement events this election cycle. This “cross-platform” social media conference attracted over a hundred political leaders from the southeas...
by Kirk Clay


Bill O’Reilly Wants You to Believe Paul Ryan Isn’t a Race Hustler, But Barbara Lee Is

Remember that it was Rep. Paul Ryan who said this two weeks ago on a radio show: “We have got this tailspin of culture in our inner cities in particular of men not working, and just generations of men not even thinking ab...
by Lauren Victoria Burke



Be the first to comment!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>