7:25pm November 5, 2012

FCC’s Minority Members Leading Emerging Schools of Thought On Spectrum Management


One day before the election and possibly a new chairman of the Federal Communications Commission, the issue of how best the FCC provides access to the airwaves by wireless communications companies may be approached differently depending on which party takes control of the FCC. Two commission members, Mignon Clyburn and Ajit Pai, are placing themselves in the thick of spectrum issues and their articulations on the issue of spectrum management reflect their divergent positions on the issue.

Mignon Clyburn, a former member of the Public Service Commission of South Carolina, has been at the forefront of digital divide issues impacting minority communities. Ms. Clyburn believes that in order to best address the demand for broadband, the most efficient use of broadband has to be made. “Access to broadband is an economic imperative”, according to Ms. Clyburn.

Specifically, Ms. Clyburn would like to see the FCC ensure that spectrum is put to its highest and best use. “Regulations must adopt spectrum policies that encourage this process”, according to Ms. Clyburn. Clearing and reallocating spectrum may not be enough under the Clyburn school of thought. The FCC may have to implement policies addressing the structure of the economy, including the promotion of competition; encouraging investment; and deploying infrastructure.

But while Ms. Clyburn sees regulation playing a strong role in the allocation and distribution of spectrum, Ajit Pai would rather see regulators take a more hands off approach to spectrum management.

Mr. Pai, a Kansas native and former partner of a Washington, DC law firm, believes that the auction process has had a positive impact on the distribution of spectrum given America’s global leadership in spectrum deployment. He does believe that the FCC should accelerate its efforts to get spectrum into the hands of wireless service providers.

Mr. Pai’s overall view on telecommunications regulation is that today’s telecommunications industry should not be subject to the 20th century framework reflected in the current Communications Act. He wants to remove the uncertainty that eliminates the incentive of businesses to take on risk.

Unlike Ms. Clyburn, Mr. Pai places a greater emphasis on spectrum clearing versus spectrum sharing. Spectrum clearing sees a spectrum license holder, i.e. a television station, giving up all of its use of a frequency band so that another provider, i.e. a wireless telecommunications company, can exclusively use the band. Spectrum sharing occurs whenever multiple wireless systems operate in the same frequency band. Mr. Pai believes that spectrum clearing encourages more competition during the auctioning for licenses and that wireless carriers will have an incentive to invest more in infrastructure.

In addition where sharing takes place between government agencies and private wireless carriers, Mr. Pai is concerned that where there are disputes, one sharer, the government, will also be the final arbiter. Such a sharing arrangement and the dispute resolution process for it may not be equitable for carriers.

From a market perspective, Ms. Clyburn’s approach is intrusive relative to Mr. Pai’s approach. There is a difference between ensuring that spectrum is being put to its best use versus getting spectrum into the hands of carriers who value it the most.

Ensuring that spectrum is being put to its best use means that government will continue to influence the business judgment of a carrier beyond granting the carrier access to the airwaves. This approach would keep the cloud of regulatory uncertainty hanging over the heads of carriers who would remain in a near perpetual state determining whether their decisions on investment and infrastructure deployment pass the FCC’s test for best use.

On the other hand, getting spectrum into the hands of carriers that value the resource the most is not only less intrusive but measurable. The FCC can identify the carriers that value spectrum the most primarily by observing the bids carriers make and noting the premium that carriers are including in those bids. The lighter touch regulatory approach advocated by Mr. Pai should mitigate concerns about regulatory uncertainty held by wireless carriers.

Given the current makeup of the FCC, with three Democratic commissioners and two Republicans, the intrusive approach as espoused by Ms, Clyburn is prevailing. Which school of thought prevails between 2013 and 2017 all depends on what happens at the ballot box on November 6.

About the Author

Alton Drew
Alton Drew provides advocacy and consulting services in the areas of economic and personal liberty, broadband, and energy. Follow him on Twitter @altondrew; Facebook at http://www.facebook.com/alton.drew.5; or visit him at www.altondrew.com. The ideas and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author, and have complete editorial independence from any Politic365 partners, sponsors, or advertisers. For additional information about Politic365, please visit http://politic365.com/about/.



Fixing the System Starts with Making it Easier for Families to Stay Connected

Earlier in the week, VICE debuted a documentary on HBO called Fixing the System which explored the ways America’s criminal justice system undermines democracy, disrupts families, negatively impacts the economic well-bei...
by Kristal High


Lifeline Supporters Push for Equity in Expanding Subsidy to Broadband

More than 400 comments have poured into the Federal Communications Commission over the past two months, and September 30, 2015 marked the close of the Commission’s effort to get public input on whether Lifeline should be...
by Politic365 Staff


White House Council Releases Report to Increase Broadband Adoption

President Obama, like many Americans and national leaders across the country, recognizes the importance of broadband as the most critical infrastructure of the 21st century. “Access to high-speed broadband is no longer a lux...
by Kristal High



GOP Looking to Prove It’s #CommittedToCommunity with New Outreach Effort

Earlier this week, the Republican National Committee launched a first of its kind effort to meet Black Americans (and would be voters) where they are by partnering with Radio One for #CommittedToCommunity: Engage, Empower, Upli...
by Politic365 Staff

Black Lives Matter Black Friday

Can You Hear Me Now: Cell Phone Video Is Powerful Tool to Address Police Brutality

Sandra Bland had just relocated to Texas from Chicago to start a new job. She was stopped by police for her apparent failure to signal properly while changing lanes. After an arrest in which she ended up on the ground with a co...
by Kristal High



Be the first to comment!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>