Politic365

 
 


Redistricting

11:45am September 6, 2012

Texas Redistricting Decision Big Victory for Voting Rights Act

VRA1

Texas’ redistricting plan was denied pre-clearance under section 5 of the Voting Rights Act (VRA) last week by a U.S. District court in D.C. Essentially, the court ruled that the Texas congressional and state maps purposefully denied Latinos the ability to elect a candidate of their choice, and thus, the maps did not comply with the VRA. So while some may see this ruling as simply a victory for minority voters in Texas, the ruling also appears to be a win for section 5 of the VRA throughout the country.

Section 5 of the VRA requires states with a history of discriminatory voting behavior to seek pre-clearance for redistricting plans from the government. In its suit, the State of Texas argued that section 5 was an overreach by the federal government into state sovereignty, according to Dr. Henry Flores, professor of Political Science and Dean of the Graduate School at St. Mary’s University, in San Antonio, Texas.

“There’s a nationwide attack on Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act, to me, this decision is a great victory,” Flores said. Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott asked the court to rule this piece of legislation unconstitutional, claiming that the state no longer needed to be checked for its historic racial redistricting procedures.

“Essentially, the court said ‘You guys are crazy,’” said Flores, who was also an expert witness in a MALDEF (Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund) lawsuit against Texas over redistricting.

In a statement, MALDEF President and General Counsel Thomas A. Saenz said: “The intransigent refusal of Texas officials to comply with the Voting Rights Act, particularly with regard to the state’s rapidly-growing Latino population, has once again resulted in the possibility that Texas will be grappling with congressional and legislative redistricting well into the decade. Texas should abandon this obstreperous path and work to quickly adopt maps that comply with all sections of the VRA.”

San Antonio State Senator Leticia Van de Putte was a loud voice in the state legislature against the maps as they were being drawn, and said she doesn’t believe they were purposefully racist, but rather, reflected partisan goals.

“The maps disrespected minority growth, so I felt we needed to protect and give accurate reflection of the growth of the state,” she told Politic365. “Republicans have the majorities in both chambers and their goal is to draw maps that enhance their probability of keeping seats, or gaining seats — and that, in and of itself, is not a goal that is unconstitutionally illegal.”

Section 5 in Texas is still needed because the racial element in redistricting in this latest round was very evident, Professor Flores explained. Although Texas claimed that it was a coincidence with no racial intent that resulted in the maps’ makeup of voters, there were several pieces of evidence in the trial that proved it was too systematic for that to be true. For example, an email where mapdrawers were given instructions on how to develop a metric to make a congressional district both majority Hispanic, but under-performing in terms of voter turnout, he said.

“I think what my Republican colleagues would have you believe is that they don’t have an intent to discriminate — but if they do, it’s unintentional,” Senator Van de Putte said. “I think the court and Congress have held that it doesn’t matter what is intended, it’s the effect.”

And Van de Putte noted an interesting contradiction in this entire battle. Republican leadership in Texas has been vocal about wanting a test case (such as this one) to be brought before the Supreme Court in order to see Section 5 overturned — which is odd, considering that in 2006 the VRA was reauthorized by Congress and signed by President George W. Bush for another 25 years.

Another interesting contradiction is that Texas’ secretary of state Greg Abbott already said he would appeal the redistricting decision to the Supreme Court. Yet, Professor Flores notes that the unanimous decision by the D.C. court was made largely by two Republican appointees. So, despite Republicans’ seeming ambivalence about the VRA, Flores said if Abbott strikes out again with the Supreme Court with his argument that section 5 should be eliminated, then it’s likely this part of the VRA will remain in place.



About the Author

Sara Inés Calderón
Sara Inés Calderón
Sara Inés Calderón is a journalist and writer bouncing between California and Texas.




 
 

 
7432022562_3733c11c35_k

Supreme Court is allowing Texas to use strict voter ID law in Nov. election

On Saturday, the Supreme Court gave Texas the approval to move forward with implementing a strict voter identification law in the upcoming midterm election. Adam Liptak for The New York Times wrote: “The law, enacted in 2...
by Adriana Maestas
0

 
 
4249731778_ab4fc01fd9_b

Wage gap exists for minorities in high tech fields

A recent report from the American Institute for Economic Research shows that in high technology fields Latinos, Asians, and blacks are not receiving equal pay for equal work. According to a report from USA Today: “That...
by Adriana Maestas
0

 
 
Solar-rooftop

Net Metering Means Minorities Are Getting the Short End of the Deal

This article first appeared on VOXXI. By Gus Portela Hiring is on the uptick, but its slow pace is leaving many struggling Americans in a lurch. As we head into election season, the debate over how to create more jobs and help ...
by Guest Contributor
0

 

Advertisement
 
m38540089_514x260-Blood-App-2

Blood Donation App Makes it Easier for African Americans to be Donors

Less than 1 percent of blood donations are from African Americans. Though compatibility is not based on race, genetically similar blood is best for patients who need repeated or large volumes of blood transfusions, or those who...
by Politic365 Staff
3

 
 
mobile

Hispanic Wireless Users Survey: Fewer Taxes, More Spectrum

Recently McLaughlin & Associates partnered with Penn Schoen Berland to develop and conduct a bipartisan national online survey of 417 adult Hispanics, and the 2014 Hispanic Consumer Survey reveals a lot about Hispanic wirel...
by Politic365 Staff
1

 




0 Comments


Be the first to comment!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>