Politic365

 
 


Headline

4:30pm August 29, 2012

McCain? Reagan? Where Have the Immigration Reform Republicans Gone?

031208_reaganobit_hmedium.grid-6x2

It’s almost a political given these days that Democrats are “pro-immigration” and Republicans “anti-immigration.” Of course, this is a simplistic view, and misses the bigger picture of immigration reform efforts in recent history — most notably that one of the more powerful pushes of late was energized by Republicans. Remember pre-9/11 President George W. Bush’s making nice with then-Mexican President Vicente Fox? What about John McCain’s 2006 effort with Senator Ted Kennedy: the Kennedy-McCain Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act (CIRA)?

Where have all the pro-immigration reform Republicans gone?

“John McCain was probably one of the most immigrant-friendly Republicans in the Senate. Latinos were the people that he should have been able to depend on. He ran for president and it didn’t pay off,” said Stephen A. Nuño, assistant professor in the Department of Politics and International Affairs at Northern Arizona University. Nuño postulates that, Republicans’ unwillingness to push for immigration reform is at least party the fault of Latino voters.

When Latino support fell through for McCain in 2008 despite his efforts on immigration, it was viewed as a failure by the Republican machine. Thus, there was no longer an electoral incentive for him or other Republicans to push the issue, because Latino organizations lined up behind then-candidate Barack Obama — even though he hadn’t pushed for the same types of reforms as McCain up to that point.

“Republicans look at that and say, ‘They are not going to vote for us anyway because we are white or because we are racist,’” Nuño said.

That kind of logic is a bit of a leap, though, if you ask Professor Luis Fraga, Associate Vice Provost for Faculty Advancement at the University of Washington and a political scientist who studies Latino voting behavior. Latinos support candidates based on policy — not race.

Studies show that Latino voters are much more interested in supporting a candidate who has policy positions similar to their own than they do supporting a co-ethnic or a candidate who speaks Spanish,” Fraga said. “These last two candidate characteristics are important to Latino voters — but not as much as congruence on policy positions.”

A more likely scenario for Republicans’ move away from supporting immigration reform is that the party has shifted its outreach to its more conservative base, giving up on recruiting Latino voters in states like Nevada or Colorado. Thus you see in the campaigns of formerly immigration friendly Republican Senator Lindsey Graham of South Carolina or Orrin Hatch of Utah a move towards an enforcement only policy.

“They do not want to risk losing to a socially conservative, Tea Party-type opponent, by being charged that they are ‘soft’ of immigration or support ‘amnesty,’” he said. “By switching positions on immigration, they are less likely to have ‘more conservative’ opponents in Republican primaries.”

Thus, instead of blaming Latino voters, Fraga emphasizes the rightward movement of the party as the reason pro-immigration Republicans are a dying breed. Because of this rightward trend, the GOP has fastened onto the “attrition through enforcement” mantra that Fraga said mobilizes the most anti-immigrant parts of the Republican base, while not driving away voters in swing states. Which is to say the Republican party is just fine with being known as the party of whites, he said; the party machine has made the decision that gains with black or Latino voters aren’t necessary to victory in 2012 or going forward.

But perhaps the most interesting take on the issue of why Republicans are no longer pro-immigrant comes from Michael Olivas, a professor who teaches immigration law at the University of Houston Law Center. Olivas contends that Democratic policy has cozied up to what were Republican policies were just a few years ago. So in a way, Democrats are actually the new pro-immigrant Republicans.

“President [George W.] Bush used more prosecutorial discretion than President Obama has — by a long shot — and he has deported and removed more people than at any other time since Operation Wetback in the 1950s,” Olivas said. “The arithmetic in this makes it clear that [Obama] is a secure borders president.”

In this vein, it appears that asking why one party is “pro-immigration” is much more a matter of asking what that means in the first place.



About the Author

Sara Inés Calderón
Sara Inés Calderón
Sara Inés Calderón is a journalist and writer bouncing between California and Texas.




 
 

 
central-park-five

The Central Park Five and the Continued Battle to End Racial Profiling

                      By Dr. Niaz Kasravi, Criminal Justice Director, NAACP Many of us would like to believe that we live in a world where children could not be coerced int...
by Guest Contributor
1

 
 
8687906946_7bf85cdb07_k

A year after Senate passes immigration bill, Rep. Gutierrez says prospects for reform are dead

For people who follow the immigration debate closely, a large contingent of grassroots activists have been saying that the immigration reform bill has been dead for months. But this week, the leading Democrat and most visible m...
by Adriana Maestas
1

 
 
cellphone_wireless-Taxation

Wireless an Essential Service for Minorities; Increased Taxation Could Hinder Use

MyWireless.org released the results of its Annual National Consumer Survey on wireless use and sentiment, and, yet again, the results demonstrate that African Americans and Hispanics find their wireless service incredibly valua...
by Kristal High
1

 

Advertisement
 
8568961099_e30bdf31c2_b

Poll: majority of voters in Rep. Cantor’s district support immigration reform

Last night House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-VA) lost his primary to Dave Brat, a tea party backed college professor. Brat beat Cantor with 56% of the vote to Cantor’s 44%, but some in the media have said that Cantor&#...
by Adriana Maestas
0

 
 
6236360208_13f55a6864_b

Rep. Eric Cantor campaigns on anti-immigrant messaging

It’s been a little over a week sincethe Obama administration announced that it would delay a review of deportation policies to give the House of Representatives “space” to advance an immigration reform bill, a...
by Adriana Maestas
1

 




2 Comments


  1. [...] the majority of Latinos in Arizona are Mexican American. Ultimately, though, as we’ve previously reported, Latinos don’t vote based on race or [...]



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>