12:38pm August 25, 2012

Democrats on Pell Grant Cuts: Ryan’s Ryan ‘Devastating’ to Education


By , The Philladelphia Tribune

Democrats are warning that vice presidential candidate Paul Ryan’s much-discussed budget proposal would “devastate” public and higher education in Pennsylvania.

“While President Obama has worked to make quality affordable education available and accessible to all, Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan’s budget plan would, in fact, reverse that progress,” said Mayor Michael Nutter. “Pennsylvania students would feel a devastating impact … all while preserving historic tax cuts for millionaires and billionaires.”

The Obama campaign pulled together Nutter, U.S. Rep. James Clyburn from South Carolina and two teachers from Philadelphia public schools — Juanita Leyath, a speech therapist and Padraic McCaffery, an English and social studies teacher — to condemn the possibility of budget cuts to federal education spending should the Republicans seize the White House on Nov. 6.

Clyburn laid out the party’s point of view, saying that congressional Democrats, along with the president, have worked to lower the barriers to education.

“Just one example is the Pell Grant,” he said. “We took $60 million that would be going to banks to administer the program and turned the program into a direct loan so that colleges and universities would be able to direct those resources to the students themselves … we were able to double the number of students getting Pell Grants, and we were able to increase the grant size from around $4,600 per pupil to around $5,400 per pupil.”

Congress also provided $2 billion more for Historically Black Colleges and Universities, he said.

A Republican White House would reverse those gains, the two men agreed.

Nutter laid out a series of specific numbers, projections from the Obama campaign as to how the Romney/Ryan budget could impact Pennsylvania schools. The figures were based on across the board cuts under Ryan’s plan, which would slash federal spending by about 20 percent over the next decade.

According to those figures: $186 million in cuts for public schools, 12,000 fewer spots in Head Start, an average cut of $810 college scholarships for 313,000 Pennsylvania college students and 9,180 fewer work study positions for state college students.

In May, Romney visited a school in West Philadelphia, where he called for larger class sizes.

“Every second grader knows that’s not right,” Nutter said.

Romney has said he would not necessarily implement the Ryan budget, which includes $5.3 trillion in spending cuts — but since choosing Ryan as his running mate a week ago, debate on the plan has dominated the national conversation. While Ryan has laid out a plan that includes a set of sweeping numbers, he has consistently declined to get specific about exactly where he would cut or what tax deductions he would eliminate in an effort to balance the federal budget.

Leyath said she’s seen the impact of Obama’s plans personally. A teacher in Olney and the Northeast, she said the president’s stimulus package kept teachers working, allowing the district to keep class sizes smaller which ultimately benefits her students, who are “overwhelmingly Latino or African-American, or who come from low-income families.”

“I am standing with the president because I have seen how much he had done these last four years,” she said. “I know he is the man to keep us moving forward.”


Contact staff writer Eric Mayes at (215) 893-5742 or emayes@phillytrib.com.

About the Author

The Philadelphia Tribune
The Philadelphia Tribune



MOBILE NOW Act Seeks to Expand Spectrum Pipeline Act

Congress enacted the Spectrum Pipeline Act as part of its recent budget negotiations. This past weekend, however, members of the Senate Commerce Committee began exploring ways to expand upon that Act’s directive to deploy...
by Politic365 Staff


Spectrum Act a Step in the Right Direction, but Congress Can Do More

On November 2, 2015, President Obama signed into law the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015 (H.R. 1341). Besides avoiding yet another fiscal cliff scare, the law, raises the debt ceiling and funds the federal government through 2017...
by Kristal High


With Federal Subsidy Set to Expire, Solar Industry Seeks New Path to Sustainability

“In 2016 the U.S. will learn if renewable energy can survive without government support,” says a recent article from Bloomberg Business, noting, “the most significant tax credit for solar power will expire at ...
by Politic365 Staff



S. 2123: A Bill That Doesn’t Meet the Moment on #JusticeReform

Let’s face it: Currently many justice advocates are so desperate for a big legislative win they’ll endorse anything.  How do I know? Because so many advocates are endorsing S. 2123, the Senate’s Sentencing Re...
by Lauren Victoria Burke


Greater Inclusion in High-Tech Sector Creates New Pipeline to Prosperity

In America’s burgeoning digital economy, technology is shaping the ways we live, work, and play. At the same time, demographics are rapidly changing. People of color are becoming even more important to the success of the nati...
by Kristal High



  1. [...] 2 million children from Head Start programs and cost 1 million college students their Pell …Democrats on Pell Grant Cuts: Ryan's Ryan 'Devastating' to EducationPolitic365Obama Promotes His Education Credentials, Putting Down Romney'sNew York Times [...]

  2. [...] over what role the private sector should …Obama shifts to Ryan education planChippewa HeraldDemocrats on Pell Grant Cuts: Ryan's Ryan 'Devastating' to EducationPolitic365Obama Campaign Introduces Stronger Education Plan For Black StudentsNews OneNew York Times [...]

  3. melanie

    What about the ones that have already been cut under Obama's administration? I just lost my Pell Grants- why because I fell short under the new law which requires you to finish a BA in 6 years, not 9. It's already placed undue hardship on part-time non-traditional students like me who have had to work and care for family members while attending college. Already untold numbers of students have been hit hard by this austerity measure. I was only 4 classes short of my BA degree when they made this cut. Why did it take me so long? I needed time to care for my disabled parents, (my father was a disabled Naval veteran who was paralyzed the last 3 years of his life),to care for my son as a single mother, to care for my parents affairs when they died (devastatingly dying just 6 months apart from one another), to take the time to change my major from voice studies after a development of asthma to an english lit/creative writing degree and to take time to deal with a personal illness of my own during attendance one of the semesters. SO, now I limp along having to pay for one class out of pocket. I was only 4 classes away from graduating. I missed my PHEEAA deadline, my loans are used up, and I cant afford to take on outside loans

    • melanie

      Its ridiculous to only be able to afford to pay for one class out of pocket with a payment plan that is still more than I can afford. They should have grandfathered in the students who were on the older plan because they (and I) were given ABSOLUTELY NO WARNING, no time to try to adjust to this. Its a huge waste of tax payer money to not allow me to finish. Speaking of paying taxes– I've been paying them since the age of 15! So, I reiterate – we've already lost under Obama. Sure Ryan will make it worse (he signed this cut into action) but Obama signed it too.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>