5:28pm July 21, 2012

Obama and Romney: Debating the Wrong Issues

Mitt Romney

The fundamental debate of the 2012 election is nothing new.  The debate of how much power to give the national government goes as far back as the Constitutional Convention of 1787.  The Federalists argued for a real division of power between the national and state governments.  They wanted a centralization of power in a strong national government.  The Anti-Federalists feared a tyrannical national government and argued for greater localized power with stronger state governments.  A stronger national government meant order and uniformity but required higher taxes to support it.  Stronger state governments would protect the rights of the individual by keeping decision making closer to those who would bedirectly impacted by them.

In the late 1930’s as a response to the Great Depression, President Roosevelt and fellow Democrats proposed and passed the New Deal.  The New Deal was a set of programs administered by the national government that reformed banking and finance regulations, used taxpayer dollars to create social safety-net programs such as welfare and social security and created jobs in public works programs. These programs were designed to stimulate the economy, relieve suffering and rebuild a crumbling infrastructure.  Roosevelt drew upon the power of the national government to solve monumental national problems.

In the mid1960’s, President Lyndon Johnson and fellow democrats promoted and passed the Great Society programs.  The two main goals of the Great Society social reforms were the elimination of poverty and racial injustice. New major spending programs that addressed education, medical care, urban problems and transportationneeds were launched during this period. The Great Society in scope and sweep resembled the New Deal domestic agenda of Franklin D. Roosevelt, but differed sharply in thetypes of programs it enacted. As did Roosevelt before him, Johnson drew upon the power of the national governmentto address monumental national problems.

In 2012 Americans find themselves facing financial problems similar to those of the Great Depression. America also finds itself facing record home foreclosures, racial disparities in home ownership, racial disparities in wealth accumulation, disproportionate levels of incarceration based on race and 8.2 percent unemployment. All issues similar to the ills that the Great Society was enacted to address. According to Bread for the World, “We live in the world’s wealthiest nation. Yet 15.1 percent of people living in the United States live in poverty… More than 48 million Americans—including 16.2 million children—live in these households.”

In the 2012 presidential race Mitt Romney and President Obama have not focused their campaigns on articulating these issues and providing real solutions to these problems. They are too busy engaging in the politics of personal attacks and character assassination, not the politics of policy.

Romney’s brilliant policy proposals are more deregulation and tax cuts.  He seems unaware of the historical realities that the Great Depression of the 1930’s and the Great Recession (Depression) of 2010 were partly caused by deregulation and tax cuts.  He erroneously claims that President Obama has done nothing for the economy. On January 16, 2012 Romney tweeted, “More Americans have lost their jobs under Barack Obama than any president in modern history.” According to ABC News, “…the U.S. economy has now been creating jobs for 22 consecutive months… All told, the economy added 1.6 million jobs in 2011 after adding 940,000 in 2010…”

Unfortunately, President Obama and his re-election teamhave chosen to focus their efforts on personal attacks onRomney’s tax returns, Swiss bank and Cayman Island accounts and job outsourcing.  In choosing to focus on Romney’s perceived vulnerabilities, the Obama Administration is failing to tout their record. They should be talking about the job numbers.  They are not where they need to be but they have trended in a positive direction. President Obama should be talking about success in banking and financial reform, as well as his immigration policy. Since 2009, the annual average number of deportations has approached 400,000, double that of theBush administration. The president should also clearly explain why the Affordable Care Act is a good idea.  He has overhauled the food safety system, advanced women’s rights in the work place, ended Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell (DADT), stopped defending DOMA in court, passed the Hate Crimes bill and appointed two pro-choice women to the Supreme Court.

There are a number of decisions and policies that those in the President’s base can and have taken issue with. I will not rehash them here, I have raised some of those issues in previous articles.

The point is, as Americans watch the ads and listen to the rhetoric, real debate about real issues is not taking place.  Romney’s not telling Americans what he stands for; he just talks about what he’s against. Meanwhile the president is allowing himself to be defined by his adversaries, instead of standing behind a productive first term. The President is not campaigning to win; he’s campaigning not to lose while the American people continue to suffer.

Dr. Wilmer Leon is the Producer and Host of the nationally broadcast call-in talk radio program “Inside the Issues with  WilmerLeon,” and a Teaching Associate in the Department of Political Science at Howard University in Washington, D.C.  Go to Dr-Leons-Prescription@facebook.com,  www.wilmerleon.com , email: wjl3us@yahoo.com.  orwww.twitter.com/drwleon

About the Author

Dr. Wilmer Leon



Butterfield: Politically Driven Open Internet Debate Should Not Slow Sound Broadband Policy

Hailing from Wilson, North Carolina, Congressional Black Caucus Chairman Congressman G.K. Butterfield understands well the challenges facing many Americans today. Comprised of roughly three-quarters of a million people, 53% of ...
by Kristal High


We Commemorate Selma With Much Work to be Done

My father took me and my brothers with him to the polls when he voted for Barack Obama during his first campaign.  We were late to school, but he thought it was important for us to be there.  The second time around, I was a s...
by Brandon Patterson


Walmart Wage Increase Likely to Start New Trend Toward Pay Equity

Better schedules, more training, and a wage increase up to $10.00 per hour – that’s what Walmart workers can expect beginning on April 1. Last month, the world’s largest retailer announced that it was raising...
by Kristal High



Barack Obama is Both America’s Lawyer and his Conscience

By Peterson Prime Ever since it became apparent that he was going to occupy the oval office, Barack Obama’s opponents or critics have leveled charges against him that his predecessors never faced.  Six years into his preside...
by Guest Contributor


Protecting and Advancing Florida’s Position as a Technology Leader

By David Grain, Founder and Managing Partner, Grain Management, LLC In the aftermath of the Federal Communications Commission’s (FCC) historic vote on net neutrality, policymakers in Washington will continue to debate how to ...
by Guest Contributor


One Comment

  1. [...] read more of Dr. Leon’s thoughts, you can visit here.  He makes very strong points in his article, but there is also the question of whether or not both [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>