1:33am April 24, 2012

SB1070 and Political Two-Facing At Its Finest


It goes without saying the Supreme Court debate over SB1070 Arizona’s immigration law is likely to have a significant impact in the coming general election. The high court knows how to pick them and its been picking the most politically toxic of cases to run on its docket as of late.

The candidate’s stances on the law are sure to be litmus tests for many Hispanic voters. While the President is firmly against the law, Mitt Romney’s stance shines a harsh light on his ties to many of the authors of the bill, his serious problems with Hispanic voters – and his reputation as a political opportunist.

By all accounts Romney was a moderate Republican Governor when he was in Massachusetts – but, then he moved. Years later in a brutal GOP primary, he attempted to placate Tea Party Republicans suspicious of his campaign.  So, one easy way to go about that: take hard right stances on immigration issues.

As a result, a recent NBC/WSJ poll reports that Romney’s favorability gap with Hispanic is at 23 percent  favorable 42 percent unfavorable. A CNN/Opinion Research Poll reports that 71 percent of Hispanic’s polled are opposed to the bill.

Not surprisingly, Romney has begun toning down his rhetoric on this issue. However, what he is saying and doing has been two different things.  Nowhere is this more apparent than his stance on Arizona’s SB1070.

To his credit Romney has begun to distance himself from immigration hardliners including Kris Kobach the author of SB1070.  Despite Romney’s statements to the otherwise, Kobach claims he still advises the campaign on immigration daily. Romney has also begun to embrace more moderate Republican strategists such as Ed Gillespie, a Republican who specializes in the Hispanic vote, as a senior advisor to his campaign.

He has even floated Florida Senator Marco Rubio as a possible VP pick, a decision that is already paying dividends.  Rubio recently gave Romney cover on a controversial statement he made in a primary debate about Arizona’s law being a model for the country. The Florida star recently said that he does not believe that the law should be a model for the country. The Romney campaign then clarified his previous statement, saying that their candidate was referring to E-Verify, an employment verification tool, not SB1070 and that Romney’s views were consistent with Rubio’s.

Despite clarifying his comments on Arizona’s immigration law Romney is not shying away from his connections to the drafters of the policy. He has received the endorsements of the bill’s authors and main supporters in Russell Pearce, Kris Kobach and Jan Brewer. Why, because after alienating women and Hispanic voters, he needs the conservative wing of his party if he has any chance of winning this election.

In another example of actions speaking louder than his words two days before the Supreme Court was set to hear opening arguments, Romney held several fundraisers and a rally in Arizona. Since his campaign has skillfully obscured his position on the Arizona law, the real question for the general election is what roles are Sheriff Joe Arpaio, Governor Jan Brewer, Sheriff Paul Babeu and former state Senator Russell Pearce going to play in the national campaign this fall?

For general election voters broadly and Hispanic voters in particular this is just another instance of Mitt Romney trying to have it both ways. He accepts the endorsement of the authors of the legislation, yet attempts to muddy his views on it. Who knows exactly what Romney thinks as he is only speaking through his campaign, and they are parroting another politician’s stance. In the end, Congressman Xavier Becerra, said it best: “There’s a saying in Spanish that says it all: Dime con quién andas y te diré quién eres. Tell me with whom you walk and I will tell you who you are.  We now know who Mitt Romney is.”

About the Author

Kristian Ramos
Kristian Ramos



Effective Civic Engagement Requires Balanced Viable Plan and Intentionality

Evidence based civic engagement is a fairly nascent field. In fact, up until 20 years ago, what people now think of as civic engagement for “people of color” was characterized naively as just minority outreach. Therefore, i...
by Kirk Clay


Increasing African-American Inclusion in Tech

By Rep. Emanuel Cleaver II (D-Mo.) This article originally appeared on The Hill, and was republished with permission from Congressman Cleaver’s staff.  On July 26, 1948, Missouri’s first and only president, Harry S. T...
by Guest Contributor

Screen Shot 2016-01-07 at 10.44.25 PM

Hispanic Caucus & its members criticize ICE raids

On Wednesday, the Chair of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus, Rep. Linda Sanchez, finally released a statement about the ICE raids that have been happening across the country. Rep. Sanchez said: “Invading homes is inhuman...
by Adriana Maestas



MISO Appoints Two African Americans to Its Board of Directors

The nation’s first regional transmission organization, MISO (Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc.) made history on December 10, 2015 by appointing two African Americans to its board of directors.  Phyllis Curr...
by Politic365 Staff


Texas State University Home to Inaugural Party Politics #ChalkboardCampus Tour

Party Politics launched its inaugural Chalkboard Campus tour at Texas State University with the Organization of Student Social Workers (OSSW), Monday, October 26th at 10am outside the Alkek Library. The #ChalkboardCampus Tour i...
by Politic365 Staff



  1. seagull70

    I am sitting here in my rented space in a retirement community in the desert of Southern California. I can see thru my window 4 obviously Mexican gardeners taking a bit of lunch in the shade. My heart goes out to these people trying to survive and help their families survive. The heat here will get more brutal as the days pass and yet these gentle people come to perform their duties on time and efficiently. There needs to be a pathway to citizenship and for the life of me I cant agree that it is arresting and jailing these individuals who are trying to survive. Who wouldnt want to escape from drug torm Mexico? But on the other hand, who stole this great state out from under their hands? Ilks the like of Romney, Bush, Brewer, Rove etc etc etc….

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>