2:55pm April 1, 2012

What Do So Many Democrats Have Against the Black Caucus Budget?

Emanuel Cleaver II, Robert Scott, David Scott, Bobby Rush, Barbara Lee, Eleanor Holmes Norton

Out of the 190 Democrats in the House, 75 voted against the Congressional Black Caucus budget. During the annual budget debate in Congress many say alternative budgets offered by the CBC, the Progressive Caucus and the Republican Study Group are purely symbolic litmus tests.

If that’s true, what does 75 Democrats joining with 239 Republicans against the Black Caucus budget symbolize?  And many of the Democrats voting against the CBC budget represent large minority constituencies.

African American support for the Democratic party remains huge. In 2008, President Obama received 96% of the African American vote. In 1992, 83% of African Americans voted for President Clinton.  Currently, the Democratic party is attempting to energize Blacks at Historically Black Colleges and Universities for registration drives and campaign activity.  The Obama campaign includes an African Americans for Obama effort.

The Congressional Black Caucus has offered a budget proposal for the last 30 years.  In 1981, the CBC offered an alternative budget proposal for the first time in response to Ronald Reagan’s budget for FY1982. The Hispanic Caucus does not offer an alternative budget, making the CBC budget the only alternative fiscal plan offered by minorities in Congress.

This year’s CBC budget proposal included proposals to close corporate loopholes, a millionaire tax surcharge and protection of Medicare and Social Security.  It also did not include big defense cuts as seen in the Progressive Caucus budget — the Black Caucus numbers on defense spending were identical to those in the House Democratic leadership’s proposal presented by Chris Van Hollen.  Only the Republican Study Group budget reduced the debt more than the CBC Budget, according to an analysis by the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget.

The House GOP budgets focused on repealing the the health care reform bill, eliminating federal programs including the NEA and public broadcasting and block granting Medicaid for debt reduction. Their proposals also raised the retirement ages for Social Security to 70.

Of the 75 Democrats who voted against the Black Caucus budget proposal, over 56 voted for the similarly fashioned House Democratic proposal.

The Black Caucus budget proposal funded Community Block Grants and Pell Grants that were cut in President Obama’s budget proposal.  There was also a financial speculation tax, a tax on capital gains and a tax on those making over $1 million dollars.  The budget presented on Wednesday by CBC Chair Rep. Emanuel Cleaver (D-MO), Bobby Scott (D-VA) and CBC Budget Committee members Gwen Moore (D-WI) and Karen Bass (D-CA) cut the deficit by $4 trillion (over 10 years) more than the White House budget proposal and $700 billion more than the House GOP budget presented by House Budget Committee Chair Paul Ryan.

The list of Democrats who voted “no” on the CBC budget includes members who represent large minority constituencies.  It also includes senior members of the Democratic Caucus. Rep. Norm Dicks (D-WA) is the top Democrat on Appropriations — he voted no. Rep. George Miller (D-CA) is the most senior Democrat on the House Education and Labor Committee.  Rep. Sander Levin (D-MI) is the senior Democrat on the powerful Ways and Means Committee. Rep. Nick Rahall (D-WV) is the most senior Democrat on the House Transportation Committee.  Rep. Allyson Schwartz (D-PA), the second highest ranking Democrat on the House Budget Committee and the head of candidate recruitment for the DCCC, also voted against the CBC budget though her district is 20% minority.  Congressional Hispanic Caucus Chairman Charlie Gonzalez (D-TX) also voted no as did Rep. Diana DeGette who is the Chief Democratic Deputy Whip.

Despite many having large minority populations, Democrats voting against the CBC’s proposal ignored its mandate to fund job training, a public option for health care and added money to annual Pell Grant awards.

Rep. Larry Kissell’s district in North Carolina is 28% Black.  Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-CA) represents a 60% minority district. Rep. Nita Lowey’s New York district is 16% Hispanic and 10% Black.  Rep. John Carney represents Delaware which is 22% Black and 8% Hispanic.  Rep. Martin Heinrich’s New Mexico district is 42% Hispanic. Rep. Jim Himes, who represents Bridgeport, Conn. has a 23% minority constituency. Rep. Carl Levin has a 15% minority district and Rep. Shelley Berkley of Nevada’s district is 12% Black and 28% Hispanic. Democratic Reps. Howard Berman and Brad Sherman, who are running against each other in a primary, have districts that have over 50% minority populations.  Rep. Lois Capps of California has a 40% minority district.  All voted against the Congressional Black Caucus Budget.

When asked about their votes several members indicated they had not read the Congressional Black Caucus Budget closely and voted “no.”  A “no” vote was the obvious default position for many members.  However, other members did have detailed reasons for their no vote including Reps. David Cicilline (D-RI) and Mike Quigley (D-IL).

Rep. Dutch Ruppersberger (D-MD), the senior Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, also offered a detailed answer for voting no on the CBC Budget. “I just got the same question from [Rep. Jim] Cooper who asked me about his budget.  I said, look I believe everyone has to roll up their sleeves — and the deficit is very serious — but you can’t put a formula on defense or intelligence, you have to react to what China, Russia and al-Qaeda are doing.”

Giving no specific reason for his vote against the CBC Budget, Rep. George Miller said, “My concern is the process.  This whole process has been so diminished just trying to keep focus on the Democratic budget and the Republican budget to me is the most important — I think everything else is sort of noise. I don’t want to diminish their efforts and all that because I’ve always supported it but I just think you have to recognize that the budget process has just become just so diminished, we’re just trying to hold some integrity in to it.”

Rep. Levin of Michigan said: “It was mainly issues relating to tax policy, so I think — I’ve talked to people within the CBC and our staffs. I have a lot of respect for much of it I just — I think as ranking member on tax issues I think I need to be able to keep working for very clear reforms,” when asked why he voted no.

Rep. Himes answered, “I’m voting for Cooper and I’m voting against all the other budgets because I think that Cooper is the one out there than actually presents the possibility of a bi-partisan approach. I don’t have anything against the CBC budget but my strategy is to vote for the one budget that I feel is the best budget,”  Himes was referring to a budget amendment offered by Blue Dog Rep. Jim Cooper of Tennessee that reflected the ideas in the Simpson/Bowles Commission proposals. Several Democrats including Reps. Ron Kind (D-WI), Carolyn McCarthy (D-NY) and Adam Schiff (D-CA) expressed a similar sentiment.

A few Democrats questioned on their vote against the CBC budget were taken aback by the question. Reps. Zoe Loefgren (D-CA) responded, “I’ll have to get back to you on that I’m not gonna give interviews as I’m walking…” when asked about her vote.  Lofgren’s California district is over 60% minority with large Hispanic and Asian population.  Rep. Dave Loebsack of Iowa said, before hearing the entire question, “I don’t have a comment call my office…”  Two calls to Loebsack’s office and to Lofgren’s office for further clarification were not returned.

Politic365 Chief Congressional Correspondent, publishes the blog Crewof42 on the Congressional Black Caucus.  She is heard every Tuesday on WMCS 1290 in Milwaukee on Earl Ingram’s show The Evening Rush as well as on WHUR and WPFW in Washington DC. You can follow her on twitter at @crewof42

About the Author

Lauren Victoria Burke
Lauren Victoria Burke
Lauren Victoria Burke is an independent journalist who analyses politics and justice reform. She created Crewof42.com, a blog that covers the work of African American members of Congress, in 2009. Ms. Burke has also been a staffer for the Senate Democratic Policy Committee and Director of Communications for Rep. Andre Carson (D-IN). She has had a very diverse career in politics and media and appears weekly on NewsOneNow with Roland Martin. She has also appeared on Hardball with Chris Matthews, Politics Nation with Al Sharpton and Up with Steve Kornacki on MSNBC. She is also a contributing writer for NBCNews.com and TheRoot.com Ms. Burke has also authored three books of photography including two on President Obama's 2008 campaign for the presidency and one with Marvel Comics creator Stan Lee. Ms. Burke was born in the Bronx, New York and grew up on Long Island. She holds a B.A. in History from The American University. E-mail: LBurke007@gmail.com. Twitter: @LVBurke. Instagram: LVB325.



Increasing African-American Inclusion in Tech

By Rep. Emanuel Cleaver II (D-Mo.) This article originally appeared on The Hill, and was republished with permission from Congressman Cleaver’s staff.  On July 26, 1948, Missouri’s first and only president, Harry S. T...
by Guest Contributor

a-Obama UN _0

American Business Act on Climate Pledge Important Step for Energy Future

Tackling the negative affects of climate change has been a top-line priority for the Obama Administration for years, and now the President is getting even more help in pushing forward this initiative. Apple, American Express, A...
by Kristal High


Texas State University Home to Inaugural Party Politics #ChalkboardCampus Tour

Party Politics launched its inaugural Chalkboard Campus tour at Texas State University with the Organization of Student Social Workers (OSSW), Monday, October 26th at 10am outside the Alkek Library. The #ChalkboardCampus Tour i...
by Politic365 Staff



Fixing the System Starts with Making it Easier for Families to Stay Connected

Earlier in the week, VICE debuted a documentary on HBO called Fixing the System which explored the ways America’s criminal justice system undermines democracy, disrupts families, negatively impacts the economic well-bei...
by Kristal High


White House Council Releases Report to Increase Broadband Adoption

President Obama, like many Americans and national leaders across the country, recognizes the importance of broadband as the most critical infrastructure of the 21st century. “Access to high-speed broadband is no longer a lux...
by Kristal High



  1. [...] More money for Pell Grants and job training? A public option? The Buffett Rule? Closing tax loopholes? Why would 75 Democrats be against this? Last Wednesday, 75 Democrats voted NO on the CBC Budget. [...]

  2. [...] put to a vote last week, it failed in a 314-107 vote. As Politic365 reports, even though it was similar to the House Democrats’ plan, 75 Democrats joined the 239 [...]

  3. [...] year since 1981 the Congressional Black Caucus has produced an alternative budget to be considered on the floor of the House.  Last year, 75 [...]

  4. […] April 1, 2012: RELATED: What Do So Many Dems Have Against the Black Caucus Budget? […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>