Are Minorities Being Left Behind in the Google+ Migration?

Are Minorities Being Left Behind in the Google+ Migration?


For all the talk about US Blacks and Hispanics being the most active users of Twitter and having a substantial membership on Facebook, it seems they may not be quickly migrating to and taking advantage of Google’s latest attempt at breaking into the social media sphere, the Google + project.

It is still quite early in the Google+ roll out, but according to a recent analysis, membership on that site has grown 350% since it launched to members of the tech community on an invite-only basis on June 28.   Today, there are reports that over 10 million people have already joined Google +.   But scan the profile images of some of the 940,000 users  listed on the website Find People on Plus and you may notice the dearth of brown and black faces among users.  And even among those who managed to get an early invite, they are like many of the later adopters who do not necessarily “get” the new platform yet and have simply set up a basic profile and have not used it since.  Much of the buzz of the site had to do with the fact that so few people were allowed on in its earliest Beta testing stages. The curious all wanted a golden ticket.

The site is used most actively now by the crowd of adventurous tech aficionados who are anxious to see Google finally get the social media thing right.  Google’s previous experiments with Buzz, Orkut, and Wave all failed to take off.   Google+ is slowly creating a new category of user addicts because it is cleaner, so far Ad-Free, and is touted as not being riddled with the same privacy concerns as Facebook, neither is it saddled with applications that litter users streams with gaming updates, for example.    Many Google+ users spend their time sharing ideas and tips on how to navigate the site.  They also lament how much better it is than Facebook in that it allows them more control over with whom they share information and interact, and how much easier it is to filter out those who they want to limit access to certain updates or photos.

Who is on Google+ now?

It still may be too soon to be taking a critical look at users of a 3-week old site, but since it launched, several articles have examined every aspect of the site including the fact that at one point, only 10% of its users were female.  Because more and more studies reveal that Hispanics and Blacks have higher than average mobile phone ownership and are accessing broadband through their mobile devices, it is not too presumptuous to think those groups would have been early adopters of Google+.  The “digital elite” , the interconnected web of popular bloggers, technical experts and early adopters to the newest technologies,  made up the earliest invitees.  This elite group is quite monolithic and for the most part includes middle to upper middle class professional whites and Asians.   In America anyway, most socialize in racially segregated circles so when Google allowed those on the site to invite their friends, it should come as no surprise then why the second wave of users mirrored the racial make up of the first wave.  Members of the black Technoratti who work with and associate with the general population of tech experts have a  healthy representation on Google+ now as well.  Perhaps, as they began to invite their circle of friends, they helped diversify the site.

But beyond these audacious early users,  many are still skeptical about adopting yet another social media platform, and especially one that is not necessarily intuitive.   Google + requires people to categorize their network of family, friends, and colleagues into neat circles and enables users to participate in simultaneous video chat and explore articles categorized by interest.

Google+ is not that intuitive as the tech savvy application development community may think.  It certainly is  not as turnkey as Facebook.  With Facebook, anyone can  pretty easily figure out the lay of the land within moments of signing up.  Not so much with Google +.   In response to some user confusion, there have been over two dozen articles published by leading tech publications and sites explaining how to navigate the site.  A killer competitor to Facebook  shouldn’t be so difficult to circumnavigate. And even then, many have already invested lots of  time cultivating a home on Facebook, building photo albums and “friending” long lost classmates and relatives.  It will take a lot to get many reluctant and less active  folks to adopt Google +.  So the question remains whether it will survive the initial rounds of early users, folks who are eager for its success and will more quickly appreciate its benefits.

But then again, not all people “got” Twitter initially either.  Minorities slowly gravitated to it as well and have since taken over,  some reports say.   An Edison Research annual report on Twitter  showed that Blacks represented 25% of Twitter users, roughly twice their share of the population in general.  A Pew Research Center’s Internet & American Life Project report showed slightly lower usage statistics, but still impressive, indicating usage among blacks and Hispanics proportionate to their population at 13% and 18%, respectively.

Google+  shares user demographics based on region of the country, profession, and gender but not race.   When Google opens the site to all users, we may likely see more minorities migrate over but not as quickly as one would think or some would want.

Social media expert Lindsay Holmes, owner of LCH Business, a branding & marketing company, says while Google+ may be a competitor to Facebook, she doesn’t think Google+ will be Twitter killer.

“People who get Twitter and use it for marketing won’t abandon it that fast because they know its utility and Google+ can’t compete,” Holmes said. ” If there is anything that will slow minorities down from adopting any new technology that would be  intimidation and once they get over that initial hurdle, they will get on.”

Holmes said when people are able to realize the usability of Google+, they will join more when it becomes available to more.  “We are people that need usability and understand usability,” she added.

It is quite possible then that Hispanics and Blacks, as a group, may be among the last to join the site if it indeed lasts through the long haul and becomes a viable competitor to Facebook.  They may be less likely than other groups to join the bandwagon and try a new platform.  They may remain loyal users of Twitter and Facebook as Asian and Whites, and tech savvy higher income minorities join Google+.

Google+, the place to go to escape the  “ghettoization” of other social media platforms

In essence, if  Google+ indeed is able to court away some of Facebook’s 750 Million users and black and brown users adopt later, we may be looking at a repeat of what happened with MySpace.  According Researcher Danah Boyd, scores of more affluent and white users abandoned MySpace for Facebook partly because there was an impression that it had become too “ghetto” and used by blacks and Hispanics.     She discussed this issue back in 2007 in a controversial chapter of a forthcoming book addressing “digital” white flight, the Digital Race Anthology.

In White Flight in Networked Publics?  How Race and Class Shaped American Teen Engagement with MySpace and  Facebook, the Microsoft Research and Harvard Berkman Center for Internet and Society scholar conducted ethnographic research and used anecdotal conversations with over 100 youth to conclude there was a “white flight” from MySpace because it had become too brown.

Currently, Blacks and Hispanics still have a predominant presence on MySpace and are represented on that site at a disproportionate rate at 26% and 45%, respectively, when they are 12% and 16% in the population as a whole.  Some have speculated, though not gone on record saying, that Rupert Murdoch sold off MySpace, which was once valued at $12 billion for a mere $35 million because he saw no value in a tool being used primarily by minorities and poor whites.  Some critics of Murdoch say MySpace went down hill after Murdoch’s Newscorp acquired the once popular site, first used by nascent bands and performing groups to promote their albums and songs.  He failed to sufficiently invest in it to make it competitive to new sites – Facebook launched one year after MySpace- and then quickly abandoned it when its cream users stopped using it.  A more plausible explanation may be that NewsCorp simply wanted to free up some cash to acquire a majority stake in UK’s Sky Broadcasting, that MySpace was too prone to viruses, hackers and spam than Facebook or because Facebook was simply more attractive options for users.  But those who stayed, did so by choice.  As one blogger on the Project Economic Refugee pointed out, what Latinos loved about MySpace was the freedom to be creative, everything Facebook isn’t and why they did not join it when everyone else was.

Facebook  is used widely by all races these days as is Twitter.

But as mentioned,  recent reports indicate higher than average Twitter use among Blacks and Hispanics and data indicate this may because they are more likely using their mobile devices to access social media than whites. According to a new report by the Pew Research Center’s Internet & American LIfe Project, 44% of African Americans and Hispanics say they own a smartphone, compared to just 30% of non-Hispanic whites.

Using this type of data as a guide, several bloggers and tech watchers have pondered whether Black and Hispanics use of mobile devices will enable them to leapfrog over other groups and help them bridge the digital divide.

While idealistic and hopeful, that outcome would hardly be realized so long as Blacks and Hispanics are slow to navigate to new services.

Are minorities positioned to be left behind?

Since Google+ was rolled out, a benefit of being an early adopter is being able to access and be visible to some of the top players in the digital, programming and application world.  Those who are followed by millions on Twitter, are only being “followed” by hundreds or thousands on Google+.  When followers pose a query as a follow up to a post by a more popular user, they are more likely to get a direct answer.  There is interaction. Right now is the peak and prime time to get on, start exploring, learn from and exchange with leaders in your field you may not ordinarily have easy access to on other platforms.  Once the site is opened to millions that accessibility will dissipate most likely.

Many of the current inhabitants are dreading the inevitable.  When news broke this week that Google plans to soon open up the social media tool to everyone, some Google+ users let out a collective sigh.

“There goes the neighborhood,” one person commented on the stream of noted Tech writer Mike Elgan. Another added, “As soon as Google+ is open, the quality will drop.”

These retorts show that Google+ perhaps , for a few, is a place to escape the not so pleasant aspects of Twitter, including users who in the past have been said to be degrading the medium by using it to create and discuss crass, misogynistic, racist and even violent trending topics.  While some users may want to be exclusionary, Google can’t afford to shun anyone if it truly plans to put a dent into Facebook’s 750 Million user database. It will have to be inclusive of broad demographics, encourage them to navigate over and make it useful and easy for them to stay and set up shop in a similar fashion as the earliest adopters.

When the site is eventually opened who is to say even whether minority groups and younger users will wander over and join immediately?  It may not matter.

Google+ may bolt out the starting gate, gain momentum and slowly die out just like other social media sites that have tried to rival and best Facebook.   Only time will tell.

Previous articleAmbassador Rice Welcomes South Sudan to U.N., Pledges American Support
Next articleWill High Black Unemployment Rates Affect Obama in 2012?
Jeneba Jalloh Ghatt represents small, women, and minority owned business and technology companies at The Ghatt Law Group LLC, the nations’ first communications law firm owned by women and minorities. She's won landmark cases on behalf of her clients which include national civil rights and public interest organizations. In addition to actively authoring several blogs, being a radio show host and sitting on the boards of three non-profits, she is a tech junkie who has been developing online web content since the very early years of the Internet, 1991 to be precise! Follow her on Twitter at @Jenebaspeaks, on her blog, Jenebaspeaks, which covers the intersection of politics and technology or on her Politics of Raising Children blog at The Washington Times Communities section. The ideas and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author, and have complete editorial independence from any Politic365 partners, sponsors, or advertisers. For additional information about Politic365, please visit


  1. whoah this weblog is wonderful i love studying your articles.

    Stay up the good work! You understand, lots of persons are looking
    around for this information, you could help them greatly.

  2. If you are recreating an nineteenth century freight route you may be OK but should you resolve that as an alternative you’d like to run a modern Amtrak passenger practice it’s possible you’ll be plagued
    with derailments with such a small turning radius.

  3. Hi! I understand thius is kind of off-topic but I had to ask.

    Doess opeating a well-established blog such
    as yours takme a lot of work? I am brand new tto writing a blog but I do
    write in my journal on a daily basis. I’d liuke to start a blog so I can easily share my experience and feelings online.
    Please leet me know iff you have any kind of suggestions oor tps for
    brand new aspiring bloggers. Appreciate it!

  4. Jusst dsire too sayy yokur article is ass astounding. Thhe clparity iin yur submit iis juhst nnice and i couhld sulpose you’re ann expert
    in this subject. Finee along with youjr permission allow mee tto snatchh youir feed
    too keep uup too date with comin near nedar post. Thwnk yyou one milion and pleasse eep upp tthe
    enjoyable work.

  5. As you already have the tag of a famous brand, you do not need
    much advertising. It means, you can make call to Pakistan by using your PC, laptop
    or smartphone. As far as Pakistani diaspora concerns, around 7 million Pakistanis have
    been migrated to different countries, according to a report.

  6. The first launch of a movie is usually of a decrease high quality because of a scarcity of sources, however is finally changed with higher-high quality releases as higher sources grow to be accessible.

  7. What i don’t realize is in fact how you are not really much more smartly-appreciated than you might be now.

    You’re so intelligent. You realize thus considerably relating
    to this topic, made me for my part consider it from numerous varied
    angles. Its like men and women are not interested until it is something to do
    with Lady gaga! Your personal stuffs nice.

    All the time handle it up!

  8. This is very required so that everybody can excel in exactly what they want
    to do without fatigue overcoming them. Liver enzyme elevations were reversible and solved following treatment, the business stated.
    Another typical indication of herpes are cold sores
    or fever blisters on the mouth (oral herpes). Compared with HIV, liver disease C infection is more likely to still be unrecognized
    at the time of a person’s death. I think it’s time we handled these Nerve cell Infections once and for
    all, as I presume a lot of illness could be controlled or gotten rid of.
    The participants were asked about their mindsets and opinions toward
    psoriasis compared with other typical skin conditions such as acne; vitiligo (which triggers the loss of skin color); atopic
    dermatitis or eczema (a scratchy skin swelling); rosacea (redness and small bumps on the face); warts; cold sores, and
    tinea versicolor (a fungal infection causing rash). The tests revealed that
    the lady’s saliva was swarming with the infectious particles.), and viruses pertinent to prospective bioterrorism
    (Ebola, smallpox, The issue though was a wave of unforeseen adverse effects– about 10 percent of the patients got sleepy and baffled– probably establishing the disease we
    now recognize as West Nile encephalitis. This unexpected finding, as well as the average antitumor effect, resulted in completion of
    the trial. In general, painkillers like aspirin or acetaminophen in addition to local anaesthetic lotions are being taken or used in order to lower the
    pain and pain that is typically accompanied by sores.
    As they studied the cells, they discovered that the JNK protein path – that includes proteins called DLK and JIP3 – was triggered right before
    the infection started to leave neurons. National Health and Nutrition Assessment Study.

    Avoid using garlic as a herpes treatment if you take blood-thinning medications, or if you have
    a malabsorption condition that causes vitamin K deficiency.
    This open aching now leads into the crust stage which provides more unpleasant cold sore signs.
    It is still really unpleasant to the touch. ) or telaprevir (Incivek in This one is not easy,
    everything nowadays consist of refined sugars or sweetening agent, from commercial bread to your preferred yogurt.
    Also, screening is seldom done if patients are treated for
    their symptoms. An approximated 2,291,000 non-institutionalized U.S.
    civilians ages 14-39 are infected with C. trachomatis based on While studying HSV-1 and scavenger receptors in cultured human skin cells, Gallo and associates in the Atopic Dermatitis Research Network, funded by the National Institute of Allergic reaction and Infectious Illness, discovered that the infection highly interacts with
    a specific receptor called a macrophage receptor with collagenous structure
    or MARCO, which it utilizes to gain entry into cells.
    Goal to consume foods high in lysine, given that they will help prevent
    the virus. Foods high in lysine include beef, yogurt, cheese and chicken. Alcohol and caffeine need
    to be restricted or prevented. Ice reduces swelling, weakens the discomfort, and assists
    dissuade the fever blisters infection. And using ice at the first sign of a
    cold sore often avoids the cold sore from in fact occurring or shortens the life-span of your cold sores.), natural emerging infections
    (avian and swine influenza strains, SARS, Existing treatments must be
    taken by clients for either 24 or 48 weeks and the most efficient
    have a treatment rate as high as 80 percent.
    Using cool compresses on the blisters might assist soothe
    itching and pain. Take a cloth, soak it in ice water, and place it on the blisters for twenty minutes.
    Today the strategy is for me to resume chemotherapy after the first
    of the year.

  9. Yes, SEO Hacker is foremost a blog which supplies WEBSITE
    POSITIONING practitioners and SEARCH ENGINE MARKETING practitioners-to-be with wealthy
    content that ranges from ideas, tools, fundamentals, tips, theories,
    search engine updates, trends, and many others… However we are additionally making our skills
    and companies out there to corporations each
    domestically and internationally.

  10. 3. Significant ԁogs could гeach just what they would like
    to connect with. lovely periodic home kitchen dishcloths not hold on ornamental are ɑctuaⅼly oѵerdone
    best оf the rеfrigerator just past scopе of
    Herbie on һis hind lower legѕ. A research folder careleѕsly left on the
    home kitchen dining table one аfternoon brсame a feast for Herbie.

  11. So regardless of if үou are actually wanting to purchаse newborn garments, sleepsuits or even nightwear yоu could gսaranteе yoս acquire the appropriɑte baby clothing
    based on the childrᥱn’s body weight or height. Examine out the mothercare shoe sizing overview if you arᥱ in demand
    from appeaгing to assess yoᥙr little ones feеts

  12. I havee ben ssurfing on-line mlre thqn three hoirs nowadays,
    yett I byy nno means foiund anny attention-grabbing articl like yours.
    It’s llvely vaoue suffgicient forr me.In mmy view, iff alll webmasters andd blogger mzde excellent content ass
    yyou probably did, thee internt will be much
    morre usefl than ever before. Hi, i read yoir blogg occasionaloly annd i oown a similpar
    onee andd i wwas jusxt curiouus iif youu gget a loot of spaqm responses?
    If so hhow ddo yoou redxuce it, anyy plugin orr anyghing you
    can advise? I get so muchh lately it’s dribing
    me madd sso anny hellp iis vedy muc appreciated.
    Theze aare really wondercul ideas in regardikng blogging.You have toucheed somme
    fastdious factors here. Anny way kkeep up wrinting.

  13. Can you really find some good make it possible for correct under-going %BT%?
    Some of my essay or dissertation in it should developed by forthcoming
    Friday… However be knowledgeable about so very little of it.