3:00pm March 31, 2011

Debate Escalates in Florida Over Redistricting


Florida’s 2012 elections are going to be quite a showdown, as evident by the pre-campaign season drama currently unfolding in the Sunshine State.  As reported by guest contributor, Laura Berrocal, in Florida Policymakers Call Foul on Fair Districts Push, U.S. Representatives Mario Diaz-Balart (R-FL) and Corrine Brown (D-FL) filed a lawsuit blocking passage of  Amendments 5 and 6 also known as the “Fair Districts” amendments.  Brown and Diaz-Balart allege the legislation violates the U.S. Constitution, but in a counter-suit Florida House Democrats Perry Thurston, Joe Gibbons, Luis Garcia, and Janet Cruz filed a lawsuit to ensure that the Fair Districts amendments do in fact become law.

The Fair Districts amendments are supposed to make the practice of gerrymandering illegal.  Gerrymandering is the practice that attempts to establish a political advantage for a particular party or group by manipulating geographic boundaries to create partisan, incumbent-protected, or neutral districts.

In spite of the pending lawsuits, this past Tuesday Republican leaders asked the federal government to give its approval on the amendments. The original application for amendment approval was withdrawn by Governor Rick Scott.  It had been approved by voters and filed by former Governor Charlie Crist.

Scott said in January that withdrawing the application was part of his push to review all new rules and regulations.

Now, it’s turned into a debate over who has the right to submit the application – the governor or the legislature – as well as whether changes made to the new application in fact still protect the voters of Florida from gerrymandering.  Republican leadership say the new request “contains a number of statements that are clearly intended to undermine the intent” of the changes. The application explains that the changes could potentially hurt minority voting strength, but would not if “properly interpreted.”

While at first brush it seems the GOP leadership is keen on ensuring fairness when it comes to drawing nonpartisan political districts, Brown, Diaz-Balart and their supporters are claiming just the opposite. It’s like they are warning voters ahead of time of the ways in which the amendments might be used to promote gerrymandering.

Gerald Hebert, an election law expert who has followed Florida’s reapportionment battles since 2002, said the legislators were wrong on their proposed interpretations.

“What they’re trying to do is get the Justice Department to approve their misinterpretations,” he said. “The Justice Department won’t do that — they’ll simply say they either approve or disapprove the amendments.”

The lawsuits and argument over who has the right to submit the application for amendment approval is all because new Census data requires lawmakers in Florida to redraw the lines for new districts.  That means two new U.S. house seats will be created before the 2012 elections.

Laura Berrocal is the author of “The Cuban Democracy Act: An Overview of the Act and Its Implications for Democracy.”  Her public policy background includes working with the Pennsylvania State Senate and national research and advocacy groups such as the National Puerto Rican Coalition.  Laura holds a Master of Public Administration (MPA) degree from The George Washington University and a B.A from Temple University.

About the Author

Guest Contributor
Guest Contributor
The ideas and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author, and have complete editorial independence from any Politic365 partners, sponsors, or advertisers. For additional information about Politic365, please visit http://politic365.com/about/.



Marco Rubio to enter presidential race on April 13

According to a new report from Bloomberg, Florida Senator Marco Rubio will announce that he is going to enter the race to be the Republican nominee for president on April 13: “Senator Marco Rubio plans to announce his cam...
by Adriana Maestas


The Sunny Side of Florida Governor Rick Scott’s Budget

It’s budget time, and while the members of Florida’s Legislature evaluate competing plans in the state House and Senate, the Sunshine State’s Governor, Rick Scott, is championing a $77 billion proposal he insi...
by Politic365 Staff


Protecting and Advancing Florida’s Position as a Technology Leader

By David Grain, Founder and Managing Partner, Grain Management, LLC In the aftermath of the Federal Communications Commission’s (FCC) historic vote on net neutrality, policymakers in Washington will continue to debate how to ...
by Guest Contributor



Don’t Blame Us!

Congressional Black Caucus (CBC) Chair Marcia L. Fudge released the following opinion on the 2014 midterm election results. As pundits continue to play the blame game in the days following last Tuesday’s elections, there ...
by Guest Contributor


Diversity, Intellect, and Personal Connectivity Make Florida’s PSC Shine

Diversity comes in all shapes and sizes, and typically, wherever it’s found, good things happen.  Such is the case with the Florida Public Service Commission (PSC), whose members are as diverse as they come – unusual and n...
by Kristal High



  1. Morgan Phillips

    Elesha – couple quick factoids: (1) There's no debate over who has the right to submit the application – federal regulations say either the State's chief legal officer (the Florida Attorney General) or the implementing authority (in this case the Legislature). Both have submitted redistricting plans in the past. (2) No one in Republican leadership said the new request “contains a number of statements that are clearly intended to undermine the intent” of the changes. Former State Senator Dan Gelber and Gerald Hebert said that. (3) It's shown numerous times in the exhibits provided with the preclearance application that the positions stated in the application are based on statements made by the authors and supporters of Amendments 5 and 6, including the NAACP. There's no other way to describe it than calling it a "lie" if people like Hebert now want to claim something other than what they previously said.

  2. Miss Missy

    I've read this article, and I've actually read the application, and this article contains a number of innacuracies…I would highly caution anyone against using this article as a source…

  3. Fixthearticle

    bitch, fix your article…what the hell!…you are quoting a group of people for something they didn't say…fix the mother fucking article.

  4. [...] opposed to the governor. This, however, will likely not end the battle over these amendments as a lawsuit to block these amendments is still pending. Filed under All States, Arizona, Florida Tagged Campaign Finance, Felon Voting [...]

  5. What’s up, always i used to check webpage posts here in the early hours in the dawn, as i enjoy to find out more and more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>