9:00pm October 13, 2010

MMTC Seeks to Preserve Free and Open Internet in FCC Filing


Today, the Minority Media and Telecommunications Council (“MMTC”) announced that it, along with 24 National Organizations representing the interests of minorities and women across the country, filed comments before the Federal Communications Commission regarding its further inquiry into two underdeveloped issues in the Open Internet proceeding.

According to David Honig, President and Executive Director of MMTC, the groups filing in this proceeding are “committed to preserving a free and open Internet and [have] long supported the FCC’s four existing open Internet principles in addition to its proposed sixth principle of transparency.”  He cautioned against application of the Commission’s fifth principle on non-discrimination, however, and “emphasize[d] that the FCC has both a legal and moral duty to ensure that its proposed rules do not – in their very ‘neutrality’ – lock into place and perpetuate the vast and current racial disparities in broadband access, adoption, and informed use.”

Honig was joined on the call by Jason LLorenz, Executive Director of the Hispanic Technology and Telecommunications Partnership (“HTTP”), an organization representing 20 Latino-focused groups across the country, who noted that HTTP also feels “that rigid net neutrality regulations [are] not the way to bring the benefits of broadband to the Hispanic community.”

Both Honig and Llorenz, as representatives of all the organizations that signed onto these comments, “propose a consumer-focused and transparency-based approach to ensure the Internet remains free and open.”  They insisted that, “because of the inherent ‘shaming culture’ of the Internet, we do not need draconian enforcement mechanisms to protect consumers.”

When asked to clarify their stance on the non-discrimination principle, Honig noted that “it’s important, first, to distinguish between the two uses of this word – discrimination.”

“In its colloquial context, most people understand it to refer to discrimination on the basis of race, sex, national origin and so on,” he said.  “The word also happens to have a meaning in classical economics, and that’s the meaning assigned to it by the FCC in connection with this proposed fifth net neutrality principle.”

Honig reiterated the importance of recognizing that MMTC and the National Organizations that joined in this filing have endorsed five of the six net neutrality principles proposed by the FCC, and that they only take issue with the potential detrimental impact that application of the economic non-discrimination principle could have on small, disadvantaged, women and minority owned businesses.

“Those five principles are what we believe are the core of what an open Internet should look like,” said Honig.

Citing concerns about reductions in jobs, investment, broadband access and adoption, MMTC in its filing encourages the Commission to take a closer look at the potential impact that too rigid rules – particularly those applied in the wireless space – could have on “the progress that’s been made with the Internet in its free wheeling, and frankly disruptive form presently, and over the last several years, toward closing the digital divide and really empowering minority communities in the digital age.”

About the Author

Navarrow Wright
Navarrow is the President of Maximum Leverage Solutions, a consulting firm that delivers Internet, social media strategy and technology development consulting to its clients. Navarrow is also a principal at Londonberry ( http://www.londonberry.com), a web development and strategy firm. Navarrow Co-founded with Hip Hop Mogul, Russell Simmons to create a social media site catering to the hip-hop perspective, Global Grind.com. With funding from Accel Partners, the primary investors of Facebook, “Wright successfully launched the product and raised the series A round of capitol. Wright also launched a vertical ad network and celebrity blogger network while at Globalgrind. You can follow him on twitter @navarrowwright.



Fixing the System Starts with Making it Easier for Families to Stay Connected

Earlier in the week, VICE debuted a documentary on HBO called Fixing the System which explored the ways America’s criminal justice system undermines democracy, disrupts families, negatively impacts the economic well-bei...
by Kristal High


White House Council Releases Report to Increase Broadband Adoption

President Obama, like many Americans and national leaders across the country, recognizes the importance of broadband as the most critical infrastructure of the 21st century. “Access to high-speed broadband is no longer a lux...
by Kristal High

Black Lives Matter Black Friday

Can You Hear Me Now: Cell Phone Video Is Powerful Tool to Address Police Brutality

Sandra Bland had just relocated to Texas from Chicago to start a new job. She was stopped by police for her apparent failure to signal properly while changing lanes. After an arrest in which she ended up on the ground with a co...
by Kristal High



Secondary Markets Pose New Opportunity for Spectrum Shortage

These days, most people rely on mobile devices – cell phones, smartphones, you name it – to stay connected on the go.  As mobile use increases, so too does the demand for spectrum – the radio waves that make ...
by Kristal High


For Expanded Opportunity, Lifeline Program Must Cover Broadband

It’s widely accepted that the combination of broadband and digital technology can be a great equalizer that connects society’s have-nots with vast opportunities for greater knowledge, better jobs, and higher incomes.  But ...
by Guest Contributor



  1. AvaView

    We have big gaps in Internet access in place now that must be addressed.

    Our new broadband policy must address this. David Honig is correct — a purely "neutral" policy on broadband access would hardly be neutral at all. It would simply continue the inequalities in access for a generation.

    That would be terrible news for minority communities and minority entrepreneurs — and for the country as a whole.

    We must have a policy on broadband access that addresses these gaps and inequalities — not one that sweeps the issue under the rug.

  2. Observer

    Good for the MMTC — more people need to be aware of the long-term ramifications of this broadband policy.

    It will write the rules of how we connect to the Internet — and it will affect who gets on, and at what cost.

    Tremendously important — and a great opportunity, if done as D. Honig lays out, to fix some underlying problems that exist now, problems that are limiting access to the Web for millions of Americans.

    Get involved, everyone, so this is done well and right — the status quo is not good. We need to do better — we need a policy that broadens access, not furthers the current imbalance.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>