9:30am June 29, 2010

Day One Recap: CBC Has Questions for Kagan on Race, Criminal Justice

Kagan Supreme Court

The Congressional Black Caucus has submitted inquiries that lawmakers want U.S. Supreme Court pick Elena Kagan to answer during her confirmation hearings, asking for clarification on issues related to race and criminal justice.

Kagan gave an opening statement vowing to “respect the will of Congress” during a 3 1/2 session Monday, the start of four days of confirmation hearings. Kagan’s questioning will take place Tuesday and Wednesday, with outside witnesses on Thursday. Kagan was nominated by President Barack Obama but it is the Senate that ultimately has the power to confirm her. If she is confirmed, she will replace retiring Chief Justice John Paul Stevens.

On Monday, GOP and Democrat lawmakers painted two very different of Kagan, with the New York Times noting, “Democrats described her as a brilliant thinker…’with unprecedented practical experience’” while Republicans “spotlighted her lack of judicial experience and sought to portray her as a legal neophyte and a Democratic operative.”

The CBC noted Kagan “possesses outstanding academic and professional credentials and it applauds President Obama for nominating a person who understands the real-world consequences of judicial decisions.”

But that doesn’t stop the CBC’s pointed questions for Kagan. In a letter addressed to Sen. Patrick Leahy, chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, the CBC brought attention to specific instances:

  • In a 1997 memo to President Bill Clinton, Kagan supported reducing the sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine to 10:1. Does Kagan support eliminating the sentencing disparity?
  • Regarding affirmative action, would Kagan ever allow race-based remedies? Would she apply the “mend it-don’t end it” affirmative policy to race-neutral remedies only?
  • Kagan apparently opposed the formation of a commission on race during President Clinton’s second term, the CBC said. Why?
  • How does Kagan explain why only one minority (an Asian American) and seven women were hired to Harvard Law School’s faculty while she was dean? Of the 11 faculty members on the non-tenure track, only three minorities (two black and one Indian) and only two women were hired.
  • How many minority candidates who turned down faculty position offers were African-American during Kagan’s role as dean?

About the Author

Bridgette Outten
A Chicago native, Bridgette has been a journalist since she first wrote for her seventh grade newsletter. Today, that passion is just as strong. She has written for several newspapers, including the Houston Chronicle, the Houston Defender, the Marshall News-Messenger (Texas) and the Springfield News-Sun (Ohio).



Fixing the System Starts with Making it Easier for Families to Stay Connected

Earlier in the week, VICE debuted a documentary on HBO called Fixing the System which explored the ways America’s criminal justice system undermines democracy, disrupts families, negatively impacts the economic well-bei...
by Kristal High


White House Council Releases Report to Increase Broadband Adoption

President Obama, like many Americans and national leaders across the country, recognizes the importance of broadband as the most critical infrastructure of the 21st century. “Access to high-speed broadband is no longer a lux...
by Kristal High


GOP Looking to Prove It’s #CommittedToCommunity with New Outreach Effort

Earlier this week, the Republican National Committee launched a first of its kind effort to meet Black Americans (and would be voters) where they are by partnering with Radio One for #CommittedToCommunity: Engage, Empower, Upli...
by Politic365 Staff



Baltimore, Low Income Communities, At Heart Of New Obama Administration Solar Initiative

From Medicare audits to riots in the wake of Freddy Gray’s untimely death at the hands of local police, Baltimore has made headlines this year on several occasions.  Today, however, Baltimore Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Bla...
by Politic365 Staff


We Are Moving FORWARD!

This piece first appeared on Cognitive Relevance, and has been reposted with permission from the author. I laughed first when I read Ted Cruz’s comment on the SCOTUS decision Friday legalizing gay marriage in America. The...
by Guest Contributor


One Comment

  1. [...] dean of her alma mater Harvard Law, she was also educated at Princeton and Oxford. Kagan’s first day of hearings Monday saw two different portraits painted by lawmakers. Democrats praise her intellect and successful [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>