Clyburn Counts The Votes For Healthcare Reform

Clyburn Counts The Votes For Healthcare Reform


“One here plus one there equals two.” “One here minus one there equals zero.” This is the kind of math House Majority Whip Jim Clyburn will be doing this week in Washington as he keeps an eye on the couple dozen House members not yet committed to voting “yes” for the version of the healthcare reform act bill the Senate has already approved. Although Clyburn has been the focus of a great deal of media attention in the last few days, much of the hyperbole TV political pundits are using to dramatize how crucial Clyburn’s role is in the process is unwarranted.

There is ample evidence to suggest that many of the House members who voted for H.R. 3962, the House version of the healthcare reform bill that was sent to the Senate last November, are very likely to support the Senate version of the bill House Majority Leader Nancy Pelosi is planning to put up for a vote, even though there are some important differences between the two bills. According to analysis by David Dayen of

Definite YES:

191 Democrats.

Definite NO:

178 Republicans

Definite NO:

25 Democrats.

Dayen further breaks down the numbers by assessing which House Democrats who voted “no” for the House bill in November have the potential to be flipped by Clyburn and Company to vote “yes” for the Senate approved bill.

6 members who lean YES:

Jason Altmire, Bart Gordon, Brian Baird, John Boccieri (The Clyburn Four) plus Scott Murphy and Betsy Markey

7 members who are possible YES votes:

Glenn Nye, John Tanner, Suzanne Kosmas, John Adler, Lincoln Davis, Jim Matheson, Harry Teague.

4 members who are less possible YES votes:

Travis Childers, John Barrow, Allen Boyd, Rick Boucher.

What makes Clyburn’s job difficult is the ease with which these lists can and will change due to shifting allegiances and the back room deal making many of these very same members are counting on to gain support for their own pet projects. Nate Silver of, a statistician in favor of the bill passing whose projections consistently outperform his competitors, has a view of the proceedings on the Hill thus far that are slightly rosier than Dayen’s count.

For essentially the first time during the health care battle, all of the key Democratic constituencies are lined up behind the bill: the Congressional leadership, the White House, the unions, the non-Naderite activists.

Nate Silver

The possibility that the Senate may not actually deliver all the changes promised during the reconciliation process if the bill passes the House has muddied the waters a bit. The uncertainty this adds makes it a little harder for Clyburn and the rest of the House Democrats to invoke the call of history in their efforts to build the momentum necessary to hold a vote likely to yield 216 yeses.


  1. Howdy I am so delighted I found your website, I really found you by error, while I was looking on Askjeeve for something else, Regardless I am here now and would just like to say thank you for a tremendous post and a all round enjoyable blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to go through it all at the moment but I have saved it and also added your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read a great deal more, Please do keep up the awesome work.

  2. Pretty weird decision from Novak may cost him the set… When serving for the set at 5-4, advantage Isner, the American hit a return on the line which the Serb, however, returned back brilliantly, but unfortunately for him, he thought that that Inser’s return was out, and therefore stopped the play and asked for a challenge.